Kris Carr

Blog Post

Are Juices or Smoothies Healthier?

read all about it

Hiya Gorgeous,

If I had a dollar for every time I’ve been asked, “What’s the difference between juicing and blending?” I could open an animal sanctuary and pay for you all to come and visit!

I began incorporating both juices and smoothies into my diet over 16 years ago when my cancer diagnosis had me searching for ways to give my body the support and nutrition it needed. Juicing and blending became—and have remained—staples in my feel-great plan ever since. They’re also important parts of the wellness plans I create, such as Crazy Sexy You (my 21-day total wellness program).

And while these practices have become increasingly popular in the last several years, some of you may still be confused about their differences and benefits. Each method has its unique perks, but rest assured they’re both fabulous ways to incorporate nutrition-packed produce into your diet.

 

The Benefits of Juicing

Juicing extracts the liquid from the fruits and vegetables, leaving the majority of the fiber behind. By removing the fiber, all of the nutrients in the plant’s juice—vitamins, minerals, enzymes—instantly flood our bodies with goodness, especially when enjoyed first thing in the morning before any other food hits your system. Just think of the added volume of veggies you can pack in your belly, sweet unicorn! Even those of us with the heartiest of appetites would find it challenging to consume the same amount of raw vegetables and fruits with a fork.

Juices also give your digestive system a little rest by removing most of the fiber (which takes a lot of energy to digest). Since your body works hard on your behalf 24/7, it’s nice to give it some R&R. That’s not to say you should avoid fiber—it’s super important for you and helps keep ya regular. But if you’re upgrading your overall diet to include lots of plant-based, whole foods, you’ll be getting plenty of it, especially if you include smoothies and healthy, home-cooked chow.

Got digestive ouchies? Juicing is a great option for folks whose digestive systems are too sensitive to handle lots of fiber, or for those getting used to a plant-rich diet. If that’s you, juicing ensures you can enjoy the benefits of boatloads of awesome produce without suffering any tummy troubles for your efforts. For people focused on healing or repair in general, juices offer maximum health benefits in a gentle, easy-to-digest, easy-to-assimilate form. I’ve also heard that some folks get turned off by the texture of smoothies. If that’s you, then juicing is a fantastic option!

Keep in mind that green juices aren’t complete meals, whereas smoothies can be. Some folks enjoy a green juice first thing in the morning or for an afternoon pick-me-up. If you have a juice in the morning and don’t want a full meal right away, make sure to grab a hearty mid-morning snack to keep your energy up. If you want your afternoon green juice to have more staying power, enjoy it with a handful of nuts or seeds. This will help you make sure you’re getting all of the essential nutrients you need, including the protein and fiber juices don’t include.

To ensure your green juices aren’t too high in fruity sugar, use three servings of veggies for every one serving of fruit. Or go veggie crazy and just use some lemon, lime, ginger, carrots or romaine to add tangy sweetness to your drinks. The lower the sugar, the more effective the green juice will be at boosting your immune system and fighting inflammation.

The Benefits of Green Smoothies

Blending on the other hand… blends! The ingredients are whirled and pureed into scrumptious smoothies that provide the benefits of fruits and veggies along with their heart-healthy, gut-friendly fiber. Folks who are watching their blood sugar sometimes prefer blending to juicing because the fiber ensures a slow and steady absorption of sugar into your bloodstream.

Besides all the great fiber, smoothies allow you to use fantastic foods that juicers can’t always handle. Take sprouts, for instance—those tiny powerhouses of plant nutrition. Sprouts will shoot right through a centrifugal juicer without getting juiced, but they blend up perfectly in smoothies. Nut butters and superfood powders can give you (and your energy levels) a powerful boost, but they can’t be juiced. Blend them up, though, and you’re on your way to all sorts of flavorful and even medicinal drinks.

Smoothies have another important advantage: They can help you feel fuller longer. Protein, fiber, healthy fats and complex carbs create sustainable energy. If you fill up your smoothies with lots of nutrient-packed ingredients, they can even serve as well-rounded, convenient and delectable meals. Plus, they support healthy digestion because of the fiber and other nutritious ingredients.

When blending up your delish smoothies, include at least one veggie for every two fruits. Start with a tightly packed cup of leafy greens like spinach or kale, and add a cup of frozen fruit (such as frozen berries or mango, or raw fruit plus a cup of ice) and a banana or avocado for creaminess. Then pour in your liquid of choice (unsweetened nondairy milk, water, coconut water, etc.), filling the blender up to the level of the other ingredients. If you’re feeling adventurous, sneak in a tablespoon or two of hemp seeds, almond butter or other nuts/seeds for protein, and top it off with bonus superfoods like matcha, cacao, maca, spirulina or chia seeds. Blend and go! This formula will serve one to two people depending on appetite.

Juicing vs. Blending: The Bottom Line

Both juicing and blending are wonderful and efficient ways to maximize your consumption of the good stuff: greens, vegetables, fruits and superfoods. My healthy, plant-powered diet features juices AND smoothies, and I wouldn’t have it any other way!

Let’s do a quick recap of the awesome bennies these two types of green drinks have to offer!

Green Juices:

  • Flood your cells with nutrition almost instantly—that’s why I call it liquid sunshine!
  • Contain minimal fiber, making it easy on sensitive tummies.
  • Give your digestive system a break by doing the chewing for you, making juicing a super efficient way for your body to take advantage of all of those fab plant-powered nutrients.
  • Pack lots of raw produce (far more than you could realistically eat if you were consuming it another way) into a single delicious drink!

Green Smoothies:

  • Can serve as complete meals filled with protein, calcium and lots of green goodness.
  • Allow you to mix in superfood powders, seeds and other nutritious foods that juices can’t.
  • Keep the fiber in, which helps you stay regular and other great stuff!
  • Blenders are usually easier to clean juicers, which can make this habit more sustainable for busy peeps like you!

My hope is that over time, you’ll find yourself enjoying smoothies and juices. They both offer incredible health benefits that will boost your overall well-being for life. Plus, variety is the key to achieving the kind of balance you need to thrive—and it keeps things exciting! Why choose between a refreshing Classic Green Lemonade and an indulgent Chocolate Avocado Smoothie when you can have both?!

Whatever you do, choose what keeps you happy and motivated to drink your way to wellness. Cheers!

Your turn: Do you drink more juices or smoothies? Does it vary with time of day, your energy, your appetite, the weather, the season… ? Tell me in the comments below—I love to hear about others’ super-drink habits!

Peace & healthy bevvies,

Add a comment
  1. Dolores says:

    What juicer do you recommend?

    • Lisa says:

      I’m trying to find a good juicer, that doesn’t have the California proposition 65 warning on it. What good is juicing for your heath if you’re going to use a juicer that could cause cancer? I purchased a Breville the other day through Amazon, only to find this warning while reading the instruction pamphlet.

      • Janine, Team Crazy Sexy says:

        Hi Lisa, we understand your concern! California’s Proposition 65, also called the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act, was enacted in 1986. It is intended to help Californians make informed decisions about protecting themselves from chemicals known to cause cancer, birth defects, or other reproductive harm. Unless you plan on eating this machine, there shouldn’t be a problem. The motor is sealed from any food passing through it. I hope this helps!

  2. Tonya says:

    How do we feel about protein powders like Vega? Are they even necessary when we blend? Sometimes I feel like I just put them in for a richer taste but without knowing if I really need them.

    P.S. Thanks for all you do! 😀

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Tonya! I’m a dietitian here with Kris so let me jump in 🙂 Because protein powders can be heavily processed, we generally recommend adding protein to smoothies by adding extra hemp seeds (10 grams protein in 3 Tbsp), nut butters and even tofu. However, there are some products on the market made from pea protein, hemp, soy, pumpkin and rice that can be a nice addition to smoothies especially if protein needs are greatly increased. Look for ones that are organic, non-GMO and free of artificial sweeteners and added sugar. Personally, I really like the pumpkin protein by Tera’s Whey. I put it in baked goods to make them more nutritious. But for smoothies, I just use hemp or sunflower seeds. Hope that helps! xo

  3. Jody says:

    Hi Kris – I started making smoothies in 1987, although I had never heard of them before. I had lost my fiance in a car accident. About a week later I couldn’t swallow food. I mean just a bite of toast got ‘stuck’ in a spot about 6″ down from my throat. It was very painful. My ‘smoothie’ stayed with me as I found it gave me all day energy I needed. I’m having one right now. 32 yrs. later. It’s not for a weight issue as I have been between 80 and 100 lbs. since the 8th grade..I’m now 67. I truly despise cooking for myself.so my smoothies are the key to survival for me. Plus I agree the juicing was quite messy and . Just FYI: the main ingredients in mine are org. blueberries and I must add a no-so-ripe banana.I also throw walnuts and almonds in it as well. Sometimes I add org. frozen spinach. I admire and love all your work, even if I don’t have time to view all that much. It gives me comfort just knowing you exist and are out there for all of us..

    • kris says:

      You’re amazing Jody! So glad you decided to leave a comment. Drinking smoothies really is a wonderful way to get lots of filling nutrition, especially when chewing/swallowing isn’t an option or other food isn’t appetizing. Happy you’ve found something that works for you, sweetheart. xo!

  4. Nadine says:

    Hi Jris. Would you please tell me the name brand superfood powder do you use?

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Nadine! I’m the nutrition director here so I’ll give you some superfood ideas. Kris and the whole team at Crazy Sexy eat lots of actual super foods like berries and dark leafy greens. But, on occasion–especially during cold and flu season–superfood powders can come in handy. Spirulina, wheat grass and superfood greens can boost the nutrition of your smoothies. Superfood Greens varieties by Amazing Grass are full of nutrition, are organic and taste great, and they’re grown on a small farm in Kansas: https://shop.amazinggrass.com/collections/greens

      Hope that helps! xo

  5. Just curious about food combining of fruits with veg. How does it work with blending? And I generally eat my brassica cooked – autoimmune thyroid. Any thoughts?

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Charlotte! I’m the nutrition director here with Kris so I’ll jump in. The food combining idea hasn’t been backed with research–just stories of people with waffling energy who felt better after separating their consumption of veggies from fruits. If you choose to consume only fruits or only veggies at one sitting, smoothies can include veggies, nondairy milk, nut butters, avocado for creaminess and carrots or a touch of maple syrup or brown rice syrup for sweetness. Green juices can include lots of green veggies plus ginger and/or lemon for a sour and tasty punch. Spinach, romaine, celery, cucumber, carrots and beets are all non-brassica veggies that work well in both smoothies and juices. Hope that helps! xo

  6. Ulla says:

    I love to both juice and blend, but I wonder what I can take instead of cucumber. I can’t digest it. (I have no gallducts, no gallbladder and no duodenom, due to pancreatitic cancer 7 years ago). Thank you for your inspiration!

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Ulla! I’m the nutrition director here with Kris so I’m happy to help. Celery and romaine can work well in place of cucumber in juices because they are both full of liquid. Romaine is especially sweet in juices and can be really delicious. Hope that helps! xo

  7. I think both have their own qualities and functionalities. I use both for my personal use and I am happy with both of them.

  8. Marie says:

    Hello Kris ! Thanks for all these informations. In your book crazy sexy juices, the smoothie recipes are for two servings. I was wondering, when I want just a smoothie for breakfast, are the two servings too much ?
    Thank you !

    • kris says:

      Hey Marie! That all depends on your appetite and specific goals. Try having the first serving and see if it fills you up. You can always save the second one for an afternoon snack. xo!

      • Marie says:

        Thank you for your answer !!! My goal is feeling.great and losing weight. Thanks again for everything you do. Xo

  9. Karen says:

    I tried the green juice recipe. I don’t have a juicer so I used my ninja blender. It was good but a bit thick. Could I add water to thin it? I am just starting out. I have been diagnosed with invasive ductile carcinoma on the verge of stage 3.

    • kris says:

      Hi Karen! One thing you could try after blending is to squeeze the smoothie through cheesecloth or a nut milk bag. It should give you the juice and leave the pulp behind. It’s a bit more time consuming, but it’s a good temporary solution until you decide to invest in a juicer! xo, kc

  10. Hi kris, thanks for this useful article. it’s my pressure to read your article about the difference between juicing & blending, one of my friends is very sick in last year, & he loves to drink juice & smoothie. juicing is a big part of his wellness, I’ll bookmark your blog right now, love your site, thanks!

  11. Shelby says:

    I am a smoothie drinker. A few years back I was given a juicer and tried juicing. It did not make very much juice for the amount of produce I put in. A little discouraging and disappointing considering the cost of organic produce and how much of it you would need to make one glass. So, I got rid of the juicer.

  12. Mattie Gootee says:

    Hey
    so what happens if I just use the juicer recipe for my vita mix
    will that work?

  13. Do I drink more juices or smoothies? Smoothies, for sure. Not because I don’t absolutely adore green juice, because I DO. Smoothies are faster, easier and cleanup is a cinch.

    But green juice is my jam. I like them lemony, not too much apple/pear and very green, so I KNOW it’s working! This winter, I barely had either one, so now that we’re entering spring (this #greendrinkaday challenge is timely), I’m all over my juicer & blender again.

    Thank you, Kris Carr and Team, for being awesome!

  14. Eloise says:

    Dear Kris, I would love to both blend and juice, but I have found blending more practical (less cleanup than the juicer and more recipe options). Plus, with the juicer, there is food waste I can’t compost because I live in a flat. I tried to do it on my balcony, but I must have missed something, because I ended up with an invasion of fruit flies, lol. By the way, do you have any recipes to “recycle” the pulp that is left after making nut milk? Thanks! ?

  15. Kellie says:

    My husband prefers juice over smoothies… it’s a texture thing for him. I prefer smoothies because of the fiber. I also prefer blending over juicing simply because of the clean up! It’s much quicker to rinse out my Vitamix than to disassemble and clean my Breville juicer.

  16. Peach says:

    Dear Kris, you are one INSPIARTIONAL woman! I have danced with breast cancer this year and from the get-go have been juicing. It’s been my miracle tonic straight up in the mornings, was my life saver during chemo and now that I’ve come through to the other side I can’t start my day without it. Self-care is proiority and I’ve found juicing with a ratio of 1:3 fruit:veggies is the way for me. Since reading your blogs and watching you on FMTV I’ve come to understand the power of blending too and as you say get the all important fibre and mix it with my super green powder. I find that as a lunch alternative or just after I get back from the gym it really gives me that boost I need particularly where I’d opt for a sweet cake in the afternoon. Gratitude xo

  17. Elisabeth says:

    I enjoy both but have just wondered can you have them both in a daily diet ?
    Ie smoothie for dinner and juice for lunch or vice versa? And Swap the routine each day?

1 3 4 5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KrisCarr.com