Kris Carr

Kris Carr

Blog Post

Are Juices or Smoothies Healthier?

read all about it

Hiya Gorgeous,

If I had a dollar for every time I’ve been asked, “What’s the difference between juicing and blending?” I could open an animal sanctuary and pay for you all to come and visit!

I began incorporating both juices and smoothies into my diet over 16 years ago when my cancer diagnosis had me searching for ways to give my body the support and nutrition it needed. Juicing and blending became—and have remained—staples in my feel-great plan ever since. They’re also important parts of the wellness plans I create, such as Crazy Sexy You (my 21-day total wellness program).

And while these practices have become increasingly popular in the last several years, some of you may still be confused about their differences and benefits. Each method has its unique perks, but rest assured they’re both fabulous ways to incorporate nutrition-packed produce into your diet.

 

The Benefits of Juicing

Juicing extracts the liquid from the fruits and vegetables, leaving the majority of the fiber behind. By removing the fiber, all of the nutrients in the plant’s juice—vitamins, minerals, enzymes—instantly flood our bodies with goodness, especially when enjoyed first thing in the morning before any other food hits your system. Just think of the added volume of veggies you can pack in your belly, sweet unicorn! Even those of us with the heartiest of appetites would find it challenging to consume the same amount of raw vegetables and fruits with a fork.

Juices also give your digestive system a little rest by removing most of the fiber (which takes a lot of energy to digest). Since your body works hard on your behalf 24/7, it’s nice to give it some R&R. That’s not to say you should avoid fiber—it’s super important for you and helps keep ya regular. But if you’re upgrading your overall diet to include lots of plant-based, whole foods, you’ll be getting plenty of it, especially if you include smoothies and healthy, home-cooked chow.

Got digestive ouchies? Juicing is a great option for folks whose digestive systems are too sensitive to handle lots of fiber, or for those getting used to a plant-rich diet. If that’s you, juicing ensures you can enjoy the benefits of boatloads of awesome produce without suffering any tummy troubles for your efforts. For people focused on healing or repair in general, juices offer maximum health benefits in a gentle, easy-to-digest, easy-to-assimilate form. I’ve also heard that some folks get turned off by the texture of smoothies. If that’s you, then juicing is a fantastic option!

Keep in mind that green juices aren’t complete meals, whereas smoothies can be. Some folks enjoy a green juice first thing in the morning or for an afternoon pick-me-up. If you have a juice in the morning and don’t want a full meal right away, make sure to grab a hearty mid-morning snack to keep your energy up. If you want your afternoon green juice to have more staying power, enjoy it with a handful of nuts or seeds. This will help you make sure you’re getting all of the essential nutrients you need, including the protein and fiber juices don’t include.

To ensure your green juices aren’t too high in fruity sugar, use three servings of veggies for every one serving of fruit. Or go veggie crazy and just use some lemon, lime, ginger, carrots or romaine to add tangy sweetness to your drinks. The lower the sugar, the more effective the green juice will be at boosting your immune system and fighting inflammation.

The Benefits of Green Smoothies

Blending on the other hand… blends! The ingredients are whirled and pureed into scrumptious smoothies that provide the benefits of fruits and veggies along with their heart-healthy, gut-friendly fiber. Folks who are watching their blood sugar sometimes prefer blending to juicing because the fiber ensures a slow and steady absorption of sugar into your bloodstream.

Besides all the great fiber, smoothies allow you to use fantastic foods that juicers can’t always handle. Take sprouts, for instance—those tiny powerhouses of plant nutrition. Sprouts will shoot right through a centrifugal juicer without getting juiced, but they blend up perfectly in smoothies. Nut butters and superfood powders can give you (and your energy levels) a powerful boost, but they can’t be juiced. Blend them up, though, and you’re on your way to all sorts of flavorful and even medicinal drinks.

Smoothies have another important advantage: They can help you feel fuller longer. Protein, fiber, healthy fats and complex carbs create sustainable energy. If you fill up your smoothies with lots of nutrient-packed ingredients, they can even serve as well-rounded, convenient and delectable meals. Plus, they support healthy digestion because of the fiber and other nutritious ingredients.

When blending up your delish smoothies, include at least one veggie for every two fruits. Start with a tightly packed cup of leafy greens like spinach or kale, and add a cup of frozen fruit (such as frozen berries or mango, or raw fruit plus a cup of ice) and a banana or avocado for creaminess. Then pour in your liquid of choice (unsweetened nondairy milk, water, coconut water, etc.), filling the blender up to the level of the other ingredients. If you’re feeling adventurous, sneak in a tablespoon or two of hemp seeds, almond butter or other nuts/seeds for protein, and top it off with bonus superfoods like matcha, cacao, maca, spirulina or chia seeds. Blend and go! This formula will serve one to two people depending on appetite.

Juicing vs. Blending: The Bottom Line

Both juicing and blending are wonderful and efficient ways to maximize your consumption of the good stuff: greens, vegetables, fruits and superfoods. My healthy, plant-powered diet features juices AND smoothies, and I wouldn’t have it any other way!

Let’s do a quick recap of the awesome bennies these two types of green drinks have to offer!

Green Juices:

  • Flood your cells with nutrition almost instantly—that’s why I call it liquid sunshine!
  • Contain minimal fiber, making it easy on sensitive tummies.
  • Give your digestive system a break by doing the chewing for you, making juicing a super efficient way for your body to take advantage of all of those fab plant-powered nutrients.
  • Pack lots of raw produce (far more than you could realistically eat if you were consuming it another way) into a single delicious drink!

Green Smoothies:

  • Can serve as complete meals filled with protein, calcium and lots of green goodness.
  • Allow you to mix in superfood powders, seeds and other nutritious foods that juices can’t.
  • Keep the fiber in, which helps you stay regular and other great stuff!
  • Blenders are usually easier to clean juicers, which can make this habit more sustainable for busy peeps like you!

My hope is that over time, you’ll find yourself enjoying smoothies and juices. They both offer incredible health benefits that will boost your overall well-being for life. Plus, variety is the key to achieving the kind of balance you need to thrive—and it keeps things exciting! Why choose between a refreshing Classic Green Lemonade and an indulgent Chocolate Avocado Smoothie when you can have both?!

Whatever you do, choose what keeps you happy and motivated to drink your way to wellness. Cheers!

Your turn: Do you drink more juices or smoothies? Does it vary with time of day, your energy, your appetite, the weather, the season… ? Tell me in the comments below—I love to hear about others’ super-drink habits!

Peace & healthy bevvies,

Add a comment
  1. Delana says:

    I bought a “juicer” but the drinks have the thickness of a smoothie. Do you have a recommendation for a great juicer?

  2. Kathy link says:

    I love both but felt wasteful when juicing with all the fibrous waste. I started putting it into my dogs food as an extra treat. They gobble it up. When speaking to an expert who specializes in homemade dog food, she claimed that is too much raw fiber for the canines. Simple fix,? blanching. She said a quick boil and then cooling will reduce the fiber and make it much easier on their stomachs.they google up either way.

  3. Terry says:

    I love fresh juiced produce too but, all that wasted fiber ….. what do you do with yours?

  4. Barbarah Gelin says:

    Hi Kris,

    Thank you so much for this great article! I love your journey and how you inspire others to live a healthy life. Thank you fo all that you do! Your docmentary and books are amazing gems!

    Ive just began this plant based journey and have been debating whether to juice or blend. I dont have a juicer but I do have a Vitamix. Can I use the Vitamix as my juicer by blending and using a strainer? You mentioned in the article that there are foods that will not work in a juicer like sprouts and superfood powders. Do you think it will still be effective if I put these things along with other greens in a blender and blend then strain for juicing?

    Thank you,
    Barbarah

  5. shalini says:

    I started juicing for the whole family last year August. Even though I didn’t have too much of organic variety to juice, but I stuck to it and what ever seasonal was available I’ve been juicing. My family loves it, including me. But off late my juicer’s strainer got spoilt, so now what comes out is more of a smoothie than a juice. But we still have it though before we used to have 7 days a week, now we’ve 5 days a week. It’s still every bit worth it. Last year my daughter was down with fever, I gave her spinach juice with apple twice a day, she recovered like so fast, she started to love juicing then on.

  6. Melissa Green says:

    I have been juicing every morning for 4 weeks. I absolutely love it. I’m truly addicted to drinking 3 jars of raw goodness every Morning from 6 to 10am. I finally have peace with my food. Thank you ❤❤

  7. Mary says:

    Hi Kris
    Thank you for the great information, I appreciate your generosity and enthusiasm!

  8. John Rose says:

    Dear Kris, please offer your advice. Had whipple surgery in 2007; must have another major surgery in August to correct digestive track (have been hospitalized 17 times in 10 years; all gastro interventions failed, 30 anti-biotic treatments). What should I eat, not eat in preparation for surgery and after surgery to give my body the best chance of survival and recovery. Am a 70 year old male…been on a whole food plant based program for 2 years. Thank you, John Rose

  9. Ann says:

    Hi, me again….
    About that juicer I bought (Breville Juice Fountain Plus Model JE98XL), I should’ve elaborated; there’s a notice in the instruction manual about California Proposition 65 stating that “This product contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects or other reproductive harm” (it also states “Applicable to CA residents only”). If anyone has any information about this, please let me know – I’m not sure if this is something to be concerned about; and if I should return the juicer for a different make or keep it. Strange that something manufactured for purposes of being healthy has this warning.

  10. Ann says:

    Hi Kris,
    I recently purchased a Breville Juice Fountain Plus, which wasn’t mentioned as one of your recommendations. Haven’t used it yet. Do you know anything or have any opinions about this model?
    Many thanks if you have the time to reply.

  11. Cheryl says:

    Hi Kris,
    Thank you for all your wonderful sharing. So glad I found you on the food revolution.
    I have a question: Is honey an animal product that should be avoided?
    I have not read any of your recipes yet and do not know if you make use of honey so please forgive me if this is a stupid question.
    Love Always

  12. Leontina Goodin says:

    I do both but my best one I like to do Is juice and put that juice in my vitamix blender to create my smoothie with greens and berries that cannot be juiced!….

  13. Joe Lanier says:

    Dear Kris-I like your website! Looks like a Samson juicer in one of your pictures? I like mine (a 6-in-1 model). Good price, very versatile and e-z clean. Check out my site at FactorReady.com and Health tab article. Especially see the “Juicing Longevity” pdf article under Downloads tab (in the Health Tips folder). Also, “Juicing Health Factors.” I’m convinced juicing can be a major key to cancer prevention and recovery as the 1975 vintage book, “Live Food Juices” by Dr. H.E. Kirschner proclaims and Chris Wark at ChrisBeatCancer.com confirms…Best wishes-Joe Lanier in Jasper, Texas (a genuine old east texas geezer…:-)

  14. Tina says:

    I was wondering if the juicing would help someone whose thyroid levels are high? If so what are the greens that you would recommend?

  15. Lynette Forbis says:

    Hi Kris!
    Thanks so much for your passion in helping others! I have your book and love it! I drink mostly smoothies, but also juice! I love both, kind of depends on my mood and how much time I have to get something ready. Although, I find, as I get better at having things prepped, either method is quite fast. Love the intense energy I get when juicing!

  16. Kristi Pachilis says:

    I love everything about your story and found you to be such an inspiration! I’m fairly new to jucing but have been loving it lately, as it’s probably the only time in my life (I’m in my early 30s) I’ve LOVED kale! I am usually a smoothie drinker in the warmer months. I just ordered your book crazy sexy juice and am excited to try out all of the goodness in it! Thank you!

  17. Ahu says:

    Hi Kriss! Thanks for sharing all those healthy tips and recipes. I’d like to know what type/brand of blender/juicer you use and recommend. What should be the minimum motor strength of a blender?
    Thanks in advance!

  18. Clare says:

    I juice what can be juiced in my little juicer (celery, cucumber, apple, carrots and ginger) and then I blend in the spinach leaves, banana, broccoli and a few berries. It’s sooooooo green I take it in a bottle to gym and really show off! Booya. Have put a big-ass cold-press juicer on my Christmas wish list.

  19. Iris says:

    Hi there
    I am in the middle of chemo treatments
    Will you recommend juicing or smoothies ?
    What is your view about the ninja nutra bullet?
    And can you please recommend good juicer and blender?
    I also just order your new book about juicing so looking forward to get it!
    : )
    Thank you in advance!

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Iris! I’m the nutrition director here at Crazy Sexy Wellness, so I’ll chime in. First of all, bravo for taking charge of the green drinks in your life amidst your chemo treatments! As for juices vs. smoothies, we’re big fans of both. Juice first thing in the morning can get the green nutrients straight into your cells without being slowed down by fiber, and juices are often easier to digest when going through chemo. But, smoothies can help you get lots of healthy calories and other superfoods in your body that you may not be able to juice or eat otherwise (hemp seeds, wheatgrass, etc.). For best juicers, Breville has really affordable and good quality ones. And as for blenders, most of us at Crazy Sexy Wellness are Vitamix enthusiasts. But, the Nutribullet and Ninja are great ones too–and the single serve / to-go cups can make green smoothies a snap. Hope that helps 🙂 Best of health to you! xo – Jen

  20. Samya says:

    Hi Kris,
    I juice in the mornings and make a smoothie during the day. The pulp from all my juicing I save and make wonderful bean burgers mixed with whatever you like. (No cheese, eggs or dairy). Either dehydrate them or bake them. Either way there is no waste , just create. Use a large canning ring to mold them. My family really likes them. These can be frozen for later .

1 2 3 4 5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KrisCarr.com