Blog Post

Are Juices or Smoothies Healthier?

read all about it

Hiya Gorgeous,

If I had a dollar for every time I’ve been asked, “What’s the difference between juicing and blending?” I could open an animal sanctuary and pay for you all to come and visit!

I began incorporating both juices and smoothies into my diet over 16 years ago when my cancer diagnosis had me searching for ways to give my body the support and nutrition it needed. Juicing and blending became—and have remained—staples in my feel-great plan ever since. They’re also important parts of the wellness plans I create, such as Crazy Sexy You (my 21-day total wellness program).

And while these practices have become increasingly popular in the last several years, some of you may still be confused about their differences and benefits. Each method has its unique perks, but rest assured they’re both fabulous ways to incorporate nutrition-packed produce into your diet.

 

The Benefits of Juicing

Juicing extracts the liquid from the fruits and vegetables, leaving the majority of the fiber behind. By removing the fiber, all of the nutrients in the plant’s juice—vitamins, minerals, enzymes—instantly flood our bodies with goodness, especially when enjoyed first thing in the morning before any other food hits your system. Just think of the added volume of veggies you can pack in your belly, sweet unicorn! Even those of us with the heartiest of appetites would find it challenging to consume the same amount of raw vegetables and fruits with a fork.

Juices also give your digestive system a little rest by removing most of the fiber (which takes a lot of energy to digest). Since your body works hard on your behalf 24/7, it’s nice to give it some R&R. That’s not to say you should avoid fiber—it’s super important for you and helps keep ya regular. But if you’re upgrading your overall diet to include lots of plant-based, whole foods, you’ll be getting plenty of it, especially if you include smoothies and healthy, home-cooked chow.

Got digestive ouchies? Juicing is a great option for folks whose digestive systems are too sensitive to handle lots of fiber, or for those getting used to a plant-rich diet. If that’s you, juicing ensures you can enjoy the benefits of boatloads of awesome produce without suffering any tummy troubles for your efforts. For people focused on healing or repair in general, juices offer maximum health benefits in a gentle, easy-to-digest, easy-to-assimilate form. I’ve also heard that some folks get turned off by the texture of smoothies. If that’s you, then juicing is a fantastic option!

Keep in mind that green juices aren’t complete meals, whereas smoothies can be. Some folks enjoy a green juice first thing in the morning or for an afternoon pick-me-up. If you have a juice in the morning and don’t want a full meal right away, make sure to grab a hearty mid-morning snack to keep your energy up. If you want your afternoon green juice to have more staying power, enjoy it with a handful of nuts or seeds. This will help you make sure you’re getting all of the essential nutrients you need, including the protein and fiber juices don’t include.

To ensure your green juices aren’t too high in fruity sugar, use three servings of veggies for every one serving of fruit. Or go veggie crazy and just use some lemon, lime, ginger, carrots or romaine to add tangy sweetness to your drinks. The lower the sugar, the more effective the green juice will be at boosting your immune system and fighting inflammation.

The Benefits of Green Smoothies

Blending on the other hand… blends! The ingredients are whirled and pureed into scrumptious smoothies that provide the benefits of fruits and veggies along with their heart-healthy, gut-friendly fiber. Folks who are watching their blood sugar sometimes prefer blending to juicing because the fiber ensures a slow and steady absorption of sugar into your bloodstream.

Besides all the great fiber, smoothies allow you to use fantastic foods that juicers can’t always handle. Take sprouts, for instance—those tiny powerhouses of plant nutrition. Sprouts will shoot right through a centrifugal juicer without getting juiced, but they blend up perfectly in smoothies. Nut butters and superfood powders can give you (and your energy levels) a powerful boost, but they can’t be juiced. Blend them up, though, and you’re on your way to all sorts of flavorful and even medicinal drinks.

Smoothies have another important advantage: They can help you feel fuller longer. Protein, fiber, healthy fats and complex carbs create sustainable energy. If you fill up your smoothies with lots of nutrient-packed ingredients, they can even serve as well-rounded, convenient and delectable meals. Plus, they support healthy digestion because of the fiber and other nutritious ingredients.

When blending up your delish smoothies, include at least one veggie for every two fruits. Start with a tightly packed cup of leafy greens like spinach or kale, and add a cup of frozen fruit (such as frozen berries or mango, or raw fruit plus a cup of ice) and a banana or avocado for creaminess. Then pour in your liquid of choice (unsweetened nondairy milk, water, coconut water, etc.), filling the blender up to the level of the other ingredients. If you’re feeling adventurous, sneak in a tablespoon or two of hemp seeds, almond butter or other nuts/seeds for protein, and top it off with bonus superfoods like matcha, cacao, maca, spirulina or chia seeds. Blend and go! This formula will serve one to two people depending on appetite.

Juicing vs. Blending: The Bottom Line

Both juicing and blending are wonderful and efficient ways to maximize your consumption of the good stuff: greens, vegetables, fruits and superfoods. My healthy, plant-powered diet features juices AND smoothies, and I wouldn’t have it any other way!

Let’s do a quick recap of the awesome bennies these two types of green drinks have to offer!

Green Juices:

  • Flood your cells with nutrition almost instantly—that’s why I call it liquid sunshine!
  • Contain minimal fiber, making it easy on sensitive tummies.
  • Give your digestive system a break by doing the chewing for you, making juicing a super efficient way for your body to take advantage of all of those fab plant-powered nutrients.
  • Pack lots of raw produce (far more than you could realistically eat if you were consuming it another way) into a single delicious drink!

Green Smoothies:

  • Can serve as complete meals filled with protein, calcium and lots of green goodness.
  • Allow you to mix in superfood powders, seeds and other nutritious foods that juices can’t.
  • Keep the fiber in, which helps you stay regular and other great stuff!
  • Blenders are usually easier to clean juicers, which can make this habit more sustainable for busy peeps like you!

My hope is that over time, you’ll find yourself enjoying smoothies and juices. They both offer incredible health benefits that will boost your overall well-being for life. Plus, variety is the key to achieving the kind of balance you need to thrive—and it keeps things exciting! Why choose between a refreshing Classic Green Lemonade and an indulgent Chocolate Avocado Smoothie when you can have both?!

Whatever you do, choose what keeps you happy and motivated to drink your way to wellness. Cheers!

Your turn: Do you drink more juices or smoothies? Does it vary with time of day, your energy, your appetite, the weather, the season… ? Tell me in the comments below—I love to hear about others’ super-drink habits!

Peace & healthy bevvies,

Add a comment
  1. Marina Edgar says:

    Hi Kris: Thank You or this great explanation for the first time I get it – the difference between juicing and blending. I have a blender which I use every 3 days. Besides fruit/kale/lemon/lime/ginger/celery etc. I add a tsp of tumeric, hemp seed, flax seed, spirulina, wheat germ, chia seeds, barley powder and sometimes raw cocao. I make up four glasses, and put three in the fridge though I know you should drink the juice the same day. Kris I would love a response from you as to whether this is O.K. How much nutrients am I losing in the glasses in the fridge and is this a good smoothie with all the add ins?????. Cant believe YOU actually answer some of the e-mails – that is Service!!!!

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Marina! I’m the nutrition director here at KrisCarr.com, so I’ll chime in. Yes, you can definitely hang on to your juices and green drinks for 24-48 hours (juices from centrifugal juicers are best within 24 hours). You lose only a small percentage of nutrients within that first day — just store leftovers in an airtight mason-jar filled to the brim in the fridge. xo! – Jen

  2. Jasemein FITZGERALD says:

    Hi Kris … I am so drawn to your gorgeous vitality and sparkle and to adding juicing and smoothies to my families day. However we all have fructose intolerance and I’m extremely nervous about it all … hence I am too scared to even try. We eat loads of vegies but could do with a higher energy kick. Does your book have ideas that are suitable for fructose intolerance or do you have other suggestions? Thanks so much for all the free inspiration you gift ….. your site makes my days! jAsMeIn

  3. Diane says:

    Hi Kris,
    I know I read somewhere that you recommend juicing in the morning. Is there a lot of benefit lost if I made the juice the night before to have for the next day? I hit the gym at 5am then I’m rushed getting ready for work & there is just not enough time to juice. Thank you!

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Diane! I’m the nutrition director here at KrisCarr.com, so I’ll chime in. Yes, you can definitely hang on to your juices for 24-48 hours (juices from centrifugal juicers are best within 24 hours). You lose only a small percentage of nutrients within that first day — just store leftovers in an airtight mason-jar filled to the brim in the fridge. xo! – Jen

  4. Kathy says:

    Hi Kris,
    This is a great comparison between the two. I love both but have always wondered what the real difference was.
    Thank you for this!

  5. Terrie says:

    Smoothies are good for when I’m doing heavy duty workouts. It gives me more lasting energy, Without heavy food in my stomach. I just love the powerhouse repair from juicing. If I’m am feeling soreness or sluggish, I will juice more.
    It’s was good to hearing in your blog that both are great for you to get in your veggies and fruits. I travel a lot. So drinking my veggies are a whole easier than eating a salad. Now a days there are lots of juice and real smoothie bars!

  6. Vanessa says:

    Thanks for the post, I love both juicing and blending, but in between homeschool my kiddos and (trying) creating a work life balance I don’t juice nearly enough as I would want. I go through cycles of juicing but if I’m not juicing for sure I’m getting at least one BIG green smoothie everyday. It’s part of my self care routine. I love it <3

  7. Clarissa says:

    Hi Kris,
    How long can I store juice for? I sometimes don’t have time in the morning and I’m wondering if I can make juice at night and store it for the following day. I want to make sure it keeps its nutrients.

    Thanks!

    • Terrie says:

      I freeze my juices all the time. It does take a long time for them to thaw out. Also I pre chop about three days worth fruits and veggie portioned out in individual baggies so I can pop them in the juicer in the am. Grab and go.
      Fresh is always optimal I’m sure. But I feel the same benefits either way I get it done. I have even juiced it the day before without freezing put in frigde, grab and go in am. Not as good but not bad either.

      • Jen Reilly, RD says:

        Hi Clarissa! I’m the nutrition director here at KrisCarr.com, so I’ll chime in. Yes, you can definitely hang on to your juices for 24-48 hours (juices from centrifugal juicers are best within 24 hours). You lose only a small percentage of nutrients within that first day — just store leftovers in an airtight mason-jar filled to the brim in the fridge. xo! – Jen

  8. Doug says:

    Dear Kris

    Are you considering visiting the UK in the near future? (hope you are!)

    Yours sincerely

    Doug Barker

  9. Michelle says:

    I love to do smoothies in the morning when i am in a hurry. Mornings are some times hectic. I do juicing when I really have a lot of time to clean my veggies and clean up a mess. But that being said I wish to juice more often. So I make juice to last 2-3 days and sometimes may add that carrot-celery-apple juice to a smoothie recipe maybe add some nut butter etc

  10. Madeleine says:

    Hi Kris,

    I am doing your 3 day cleanse with a blender… I’m just not drinking as much and not injesting all the pulp.. is that OK?

    Madeleine

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hey Madeleine! I’m the nutrition director here at KrisCarr.com, so I’ll jump in. Blending your green juice drink ingredients is wonderful — if your digestion system gets wonky, just pull back on even more of the pulp. xo – Jen

  11. Kelly says:

    Hi I was just wondering if anyone could tell me if I would sill get lots of nutrients of I blended or juiced a drink at home and then drank it hours later as a snack? Thank you!!

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Yes, Kelly! You lose a small percentage of nutrients over time due to air exposure, but not that many. We recommend consuming your green drinks within 24 hours though. Cheers! xo Jen (nutrition director at Crazy Sexy Wellness)

  12. Brittney says:

    Hi kris! Totally love you, been following you since I was 17! (25 now) you’re actually my first role model when I decided I wanted to be a Life Coach.. Now fan-girling aside, I wanted to ask a question- you mentioned if a person has digestive issues then lots of fiber may not be the best idea- but I’ve always been under the impression if one has digestive pains and problems they WANT more fiber! So now I’m confused. why is it that you want less fiber? Cause maybe that’s why my pains still remain (and have increased) even with all this smoothie-ing I’ve been doing.

    Thanks! You’re the bestest!!!
    Can’t wait to see get your book in the mail! Been looking every day this week on my front porch!
    Xoxo Brittney

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hey Brittney! I’m the nutrition director here at Crazy Sexy Wellness, so I’ll chime in for Kris. Fiber is amazing, and most people don’t get enough. But, it’s also possible that fibrous foods may cause lots of gas, especially if you’re not used to eating them. It’s also possible that if you have an irritable bowel or Crohn’s disease, that raw veggies may be especially troublesome. In those cases, green juices give you all the plant nutrition without the potentially upsetting fiber. It’s also important to keep in mind that if you’ve increased fiber, you definitely need to increase your fluid intake so that you don’t get constipated. It’s all a balancing act. Hope that helps! xo – Jen

  13. Melanie says:

    Hello Kris,
    I am extremely new to this way of eating. I have adrenal fatigue & I am extremely sensitive to the foods I eat. I have been searching for a diet to help me manage my adrenal fatigue. Could you give me some advice as to wether this way of eating would be helpful & why? I know it works for cancer. What is your opinion regarding auto immune disorders? Thank you for any feed back that you might have.
    Always tired,
    Melanie

  14. Manisha says:

    Gr8 Article on difference between Juicing & Blending ! Very simple n logical comparision. Usually the diet n health articles are cramped up with too many conclusions ! My only Question is “it is okay to juice once a day & consume untill the next day , ‘ or will it loose its nutritional value by doing so ? ?? ( storing until nxt day dosent mean freezing ! Just keeping in the refrigerator ! )

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hey Manisha! I’m the nutrition director here at Crazy Sexy Wellness, so I’ll jump in for Kris. It’s totally fine to drink your green drinks the next day (or within 24 hours). Just store them in the fridge, filled to the brim in a Mason jar or other BPA-free container. They’ll lose a bit of freshness and a touch of nutrient-power, but they’re still liquid green gold. Hope that helps! – xo Jen

  15. Jackie says:

    Hi Kris, I am new to this world and am struggling. I have metastatic breast cancer and believe that nutrition is the answer to this and other health concerns. Which blender and juicer do you recommend? I have a nutribullet currently. Is that sufficient or should I invest in something a little more durable? I ordered your book yesterday and can’t wait for it to arrive!

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Jackie! I’m the nutrition director here at Crazy Sexy Wellness so I’ll jump in for Kris. The nutribullet is a great one and if it is helping you to drink more green smoothies, then it’s especially a good one. As for a juicer, for efficiency, cost savings, and easy clean-up, we recommend centrifugal juicers. Some good ones to check out: Breville Ikon Multi-Speed, Breville Juice Fountain Compact (a smaller juicer, great for apartment living), and the Omega 4000. Hope that helps! xo – Jen

  16. Jen Cushman says:

    Thanks for this blog post. I just got my copy of Crazy Sexy Juice yesterday from Hay House and stayed up late into the night reading it. Since following you, I’ve been committed to making green drinks. However, I’ve been blending because it didn’t feel right to spend so much money on a juicing system, but my tummy gets too over full from all that fiber/pulp. After this post and also your fab book, I realize that it does make sense to have both machines. I’ll be spending some of my hard-earned $ on a good juicer now and feel happy about the purchase. Keep on rockin’ it. Good to see such well deserved success!

  17. Sylma Vasquez says:

    Hi Kris

    I know you’re busy but I just needed some help. I did juice a lot and felt great. To cut it all short I ended up getting Endometrial cancer. I had a hysterectomy then got pulmonary embolism because of the surgery. My doctors were all shocked that these things happened to me. Although they said the cancer was most likely my estrogen levels. They believe they could have been too high. I did not need any other treatment. I thought maybe the green juices were what provoked the PE. No proof on that. Now I haven’t had a green juice in 7 months but I will start soon. I was eating great and feeling great. I couldn’t understand what happened. Anyway during those cat scans they saw what they believe is a liver hemangioma. Now they want me to get an MRI. Really? Which people can be born with it. Which is fine but one doctor said it didn’t look like that’s what it is. I really feel like I don’t want to have the MRI I just don’t want to know. I feel good beside going through the hysterectomy. I di believe in God and I am spiritual and have my faith. I will start my juices again. I have introduced more veggies in my diet. I don’t follow a per se diet. I just think about what Im putting in my mouth. I’ve been eating that way I believe maybe in the last 3 years that’s whT I couldn’t understand everything that was happening to me. I try to eat as organic as affordably possible. I live in Long Island and believe there’s is a huge cluster here of cancer.
    I just wanted to see if you recommend anything as far as taking care of my liver. Do green juices make the liver work harder? I wish I had a holistic doctor around here. I wish. Dr T Colin Campbell lived by me. Lol.
    Thank you for everything that you do and have done.
    I’m sorry about my whole sob story. I just don’t know who to talk to about this.
    Thank you again

    Syl

    • I have only just found you yippee!!! So glad I did. Diagnosed recently with lymphoma! Smoothies everyday for breakfast loaded with raw greens, kefir yoghurt, blueberries and almonds, vitamin c powder and a few other goodies keep me going all morning. I love the Vitamix. That and my Hurom juicer are the best investments ever. My question to you Kris is this. My integrative doctor says eat meat, eggs Fish and nuts seeds and greens mostly. However most healthy anti cancer foods are meat free plant based foods. Which is best? I just bought your Crazy Sexy Kitchen book for recipes. Can’t wait for it to arrive. Thankyou for what you do, and have done for us peeps. Love and hugs from Australia .

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hi Syl! I’m the nutrition director here at Crazy Sexy Wellness, so I’ll chime in for Kris. Your liver LOVES veggies! Foods that put a strain on your liver include fatty foods, high-protein foods and especially high-protein diets, and simple carbs and sugar. Here is a fantastic research summary from 2015 on the benefits of plants for your liver. The stars include broccoli, beets, and more: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4499388/ Hope that helps! xo – Jen

  18. gonzalo ramirez casanova says:

    Hola Kris, nice to meet you, me parece extraordinario tu experiencia y tus resultados.. tengo muchos años cumplidos, pèro debo contarte que tengo mas de 30 años tomando mis mezclas de batidos terapéuticos-nutricionales y la experiencia es muy gratificante, como ejemplo te puedo decir que mis mañanas comienzan con una mezcla de: pepino ,remolacha, zanahoria, brocoli, espinaca aloe-vera… y otros mezclas mas, los resultados han sido fabulosos. Actualmente me desempeño como coach-mentor en terapias nutricionales y salud emocional… He tenido muy buena suerte al encontrar tus libros, voy a comprarlos y ampliar mis conocimientos te de terapias a través de los jugos nutricionales….recibe un cordial saludo..Gonzalo

  19. Kelly says:

    Question: Does freezing green juice damage all the good things in the juice? My blender is not able to blend kale as fine as I would like (and cannot afford a Vitamix right now) so I was going to juice the kale and freeze in ice cube trays that I can then include in smoothies. But I don’t want to be denaturing all things good about juicing.

    • Jen Reilly, RD says:

      Hey Kelly! I’m the nutrition director here at Crazy Sexy Wellness, so I’ll chime in for Kris. Freezing juiced veggies causes a small percentage of the water-soluble nutrients to disappear, but not so much that freezing isn’t a great option. Freezing is also a great option for busy times—and any solution that helps you drink your greens is a good solution in our book! We recommend freezing juiced veggies in either BPA-free plastic water bottles or mason jars. Be sure to leave some space up at the top (about an inch or so) because your liquids will expand as they freeze. Frozen juices should last for about 10 days, but be sure to freeze them directly after you make them, so that you maintain their freshness. When you’re ready to defrost, you can defrost them for a few hours at room temperature, or for 10 to 12 hours in the fridge, or pop them right into a smoothie. Hope that helps! xo – Jen

  20. Sarah says:

    I have been using smoothies but in winter I dont like the idea of having raw and cold drinks. what do you suggest? Also, I am not so sure if I want to use a protein powder coz its expensive and also processed. So what do you suggest about adding proteins in my smoothies and if its just juice, what is your commenst about protein?
    Thank you so much

    • Kris Carr says:

      Hi Sarah, you could try using room temperature produce in your juices and smoothies when the weather gets chilly. Also, nuts and seeds and nut/seed butters are great protein boosters for smoothies (hemp seeds are especially good!)—you definitely don’t have to use protein powder. 🙂

1 2 3 4 5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KrisCarr.com