Blog Post

Supplements for women: Find out what you may need & why

read all about it

Hi Gorgeous,

My supplement plan has changed over the past ten years as many times as my wardrobe.

It’s not a one-size-fits-all fixed approach, which can make supplement selection a bit daunting. As always, I recommend that you work with a holistic practitioner or functional medicine MD to find the right supplements for your needs. And of course make sure you’re getting most of your vitamins and minerals from whole foods, but if you’re going supplement there are some general guidelines.

I may be a nutrition and science nerd, but I’m not a MD. So I reached out to one of my trusted friends, Aviva Romm, Integrative MD, and asked her to weigh in. Aviva uses her combined skills as a Yale-trained MD and Board Certified family physician, midwife, and herbalist to help women not only heal their bodies and minds, but transform their lives. Our conversation walks you through how to choose supplements whether you’re a college freshman, mother, busy biz maven or world-traveling retiree. Let’s get started!

KC: How do you begin building a supplement plan that meets your needs?

AR: Supplements come in handy because they bridge the gap between your diet and your phytonutrient needs—helping you feel on top of your game. But standing at the shelves in a health food store can be overwhelming when you’re trying to add supplements to your life. There are so many choices!

Here are a few tips to make choosing supplements easier:

  • Seek guidance from a professional first: Rather than just buying a bunch of random supplements, make the investment in an appointment with an integrative or functional medicine doctor, a naturopathic physician, or a savvy nutritionist to hone in on your specific needs. You can find a functional medicine doctor here. This will actually save you time and money. Ideally, she will give you a detailed plan of the best supplements for YOU, along with brand recommendations.
  • Go to the right place: You can often find better quality, organic, non-GMO, food-based supplements at higher-end natural foods stores.
  • Ask for directions while shopping: Natural food stores have staff dedicated to helping you, which comes in handy if you haven’t had a consultation with a health professional yet or have additional questions. They are paid by the store, not the supplement companies. While they are not experts and should not be giving medical or health advice, they can help you narrow down the choices and make an educated decision.
  • Pick a few companies you like and stick with them: Most companies carry a large product line. So once you’ve found a company you trust, they’ll probably offer what you need. A few I use are Rainbow Light, New Chapter, and Jarrow. There are also many quality brands sold only by licensed physicians. For example, Designs for Health, Metagenics, and Integrative Therapeutics.
  • Avoid unnecessary ingredients: Many supplements contain fillers, binders, colors, flavors, and other additives. Some of these might be necessary to hold the pills together, but go for the simplest products with the fewest additives.
  • Avoid products with “miracle claims.” If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is!

 

KC: What are the basic supplements you’d recommend women take daily?

AR: I recommend the following basic supplements for all women:

  • Multivitamin: Taking a multivitamin daily helps make sure you have the bases covered. I prefer Rainbow Light Women’s One, which is whole foods based, and only requires taking 1 pill daily. But any whole foods multi is usually a good bet. Go for non-GMO, organic, and free of dyes, additives, and colorings.
  • Vitamin D3, 2000 units: D is responsible for hundreds of functions in the body, from healthy immunity to healthy bones. An alternative source: Vitamin D2 or lichen-sourced D3 (plant-based). Unfortunately, I can’t give you a definitive answer as to whether vitamin D2 or lichen-sourced D3 is as usable by the body as animal-based vitamin D3. For more info on plant-based vs. animal-based vitamin D, check out this Vegetarian Resource Group article. Although you do get vitamin D from sun exposure, it may not be enough. It’s best to get tested before supplementing so that you know how much you need. Ask your doctor to have your 25,OHD level checked. An ideal test result should be between 40 and 80.
  • Fish oil, 1-2 capsules daily: Omega-3 fats are important for reducing inflammation, heart health, mood, mind, hair, and maintaining healthy weight. An alternative source: DHA and/or EPA (Plant-based Omega-3s). Vegans can take algae-sourced DHA, such as Life’s DHA. Just keep in mind that DHA is not as easily converted to EPA, so you’ll need to take a higher dose. Rejuvenation Science Labs has a vegan DHA and EPA supplement, which covers both bases, although I have not personally tried this brand.
  • 1 tablespoon fresh ground flax seed daily: Supports healthy elimination and helps keep hormones balanced. Ground flax seed can be added to a smoothie, sprinkled on salads or grains, mixed into nut butter and spread as usual, or even baked into cookies or crackers.
  • Magnesium glycinate, 600 mg daily (most women are low). Magnesium supports healthy bones, restful sleep, relaxed muscles, and balanced mood.
  • A broad spectrum probiotic that contains Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterum strains, daily if you have gas and bloating, or a few times weekly to optimize digestion.

In addition, you may want to consider these supplements depending on your personal health goals and needs (once again check with your doctor). For example, if you’re vegan you should consider B-12. If you’re having adrenal issues, you could take adrenal support. Please note that these supplements may not be necessary for everyone and this is not a comprehensive list. These are just a few ideas to get your wellness wheels thinking…

  • Magnesium citrate, 300-800 mg before bed if you are constipated.
  • Iodine: Many women are deficient and it’s needed for healthy thyroid function. Only a tiny amount is needed so you can take a multivitamin that contains trace amounts, or add dulse seaweed flakes, 2 teaspoons daily, to your food.
  • A digestive enzyme if you have gas and bloating—though it’s best to figure out the underlying causes.
  • B-12 (2.4 micrograms per day, especially important for vegans since B-12 is not found in unfortified plant-based foods): If taking B12 orally, take it sublingually (under the tongue for quick absorption into the bloodstream). Lastly, make sure you choose a B12 in the form of methylcobalamin (check label), since this form of B12 is absorbed best in your body.
  • Adrenal support blend: If you’re experiencing chronic stress, fatigue, foggy thinking and sleep issues, you may have an adrenal imbalance. It’s good idea to meet with your healthcare provider if these symptoms sound familiar. I recommend the following adrenal support blend supplements to my patients: Stress Manager (Herb Pharm), Adrenal Support (Gaia Herbs), Vital Adapt (Natura Natural Products), and HPA Adapt (Integrative Therapeutics).

KC: How can women shift their supplement plan to meet their needs throughout the years?

AR: Here’s what I’d recommend right before, during pregnancy, and while breastfeeding.

Take a prenatal multivitamin, get 400 mcg of folic acid, or if you have the MTHFR genetic mutation, 800 mcg of methylfolate daily. MTHFR is a gene that allows us to use our folate from veggies or folic acid from supplements, which is important for heart and blood vessel health, the nervous system, and detoxification. Folate is critical for the health of pregnant women and for baby’s growing brain and nervous system. Thirty percent of us have a genetic mutation that prevents us from using the folate in green veggies so the methylfolate provides extra “health insurance.”

Get at least 800 units of Vitamin D3 in pregnancy and while breastfeeding to prevent problems like gestational diabetes, and to make sure baby gets enough vitamin D through your breastmilk. Vegan moms can take vitamin D2, but given the benefits of vitamin D, including lower risk of gestational diabetes in pregnancy, this might be a time when it’s worth considering the non-vegan form if possible. Most pregnant women are low in Omega-3 fats, so taking a daily fish oil supplement is important (or plant-based options mentioned above). Nordic Naturals makes a nice one for pregnant mamas.

In addition to my basic recommendations for all women, I recommend considering these supplements for women in their 50s and beyond:

  • Accumulated oxidative stress: The impact of the environment on our body from years of just living and being exposed to the toxins in our world. This means being really mindful to eat a diet rich in fruits and vegetables that contain antioxidants, and taking a multivitamin as well as taking 500-2000 mg/day of Resveratrol (talk with your doctor first if you are on blood thinners).
  • Our bones: As we age we can lose bone density, especially if we’re not doing regular weight-bearing exercise, so it’s important to get daily vitamin D3, at least 1000 units, and approximately 800 mg of calcium citrate, 400 mg of magnesium citrate, and vitamins K1 and K2 (about 50 mg combined). Also boron, about 0.5 mg/day.
  • Nutrient absorption: Stomach acid, which breaks down nutrients in the digestive process, declines with age. I recommend that women in their late 50s, and any women with bone density problems, take 1-2 capsules of betaine HCL with meals. This is especially important for women taking a PPI like Prilosec for reflux. However, check with your doctor before taking betaine HCL if you have stomach ulcers.
  • Inflammation: As our estrogen declines, we’re more susceptible to problems due to inflammation. A favorite supplement for this is turmeric in its concentrated form called curcumin. I recommend 1000-2000 mg of curcumin daily. I use a product called Meriva, and also like Turmeric Supreme by Gaia Herbs.
  • Heart and general muscle vigor: CoQ10 is essential to take if you’re using a statin drug, or even red yeast rice, or high cholesterol, as these use up CoQ10 and can affect your heart and muscle health. A typical dose is 200 mg/day.
  • Premature aging: Resveratrol is the nutrient that makes red wine, grapes, and many dark colored fruits act as antioxidants, keeping us from aging prematurely. Food sources are important, and in addition you can supplement with 200 mg daily.

KC: Thanks, Aviva!

I hope these tips and recommendations give you the information you need to work with a practitioner and create a supplement plan that will fit your unique needs. Even though I eat a nutrient-dense diet and drink plenty of green drinks, I’ve seen a huge difference in my health since refining my daily supplements.

Your turn: What supplement have you found most beneficial to your health?

Peace & vitality,

Add a comment
  1. chuck says:

    hello there.
    I wish you much joy and helath.
    do you have suplements for men as well?.
    warm regards
    chuck

  2. Darlene graves says:

    I am taking ACtonEL for osteoporosis for about one year now. I would much prefer to treat Osteoporosis with food and/or supplements to avoid the med’s side effect especially jaw necrosis, joint and bone pain. Any suggestions?

  3. iliana hanell says:

    Hi, I have been through a breast cancer last year, I am 40 years old, and I don’t know what supplements should I take, living in Mexico city, unfortunately I don’t have a good doctor who can help me through this, can you tell me what supplements do you recommend for people like me? The basics please.
    Thank you!!

  4. Kim says:

    Thanks for the great information! I am currently pre-menopausal, and am fortunate enough to be friends with a naturopathic physician, who I am meeting with soon to help me select some supplements to address my changing issues. Right now, the thing that has helped me the most is my low-sodium, barely-any-dairy nutrition plan. Being overweight, with history of cancer on my mom’s side, and heart disease from my father’s side, knowing that you have issues to address at all is a huge step. I went for years never worrying about my health, taking my good cholesterol levels for granted (they still are, but that does not equate to good health!), and now spend a lot of time trying not to have regrets, but to just move forward from this point. Thanks for the inspiration, Kris!! <3

  5. BEATRIZ RINTELEN says:

    Can you pls recommend a specific brand for the B12 supplement? Thank you

  6. Aeonie Ostik-Smith says:

    I find that vitamin c with bioflavanoids helps me with most problems but I think it especially good when it come to colds and flu.

  7. Janene Hackl says:

    Helllo! Thank you for your information. Have you looked at Juice Plus? It is not a vitamin, it is whole food nutrition in a capsule. Fruits and vegetables. Please check out my website, because this should definitely be on that list. It bridges the gap between what we should eat and actually do eat. Thank you!!

  8. Lisa F says:

    I think it’s important to remind people that while supplementation can be helpful, it is important to know that many foods and drinks, coffee especially, can hinder and inhibit the absorption or increase secretion of many minerals and nutrients. I was told to take my calcium and D and Magnesium at night before bed, that coffee is bad to fat solubles, and that if you’re taking something that is not made well or can increase fatigue as your body tries to absorb it.

    I also have a question about Fish Oil and DHA. Most people tell me how many to take but rarely ever mention the recommended mg’s. Does anyone have any idea on a good amount of DHA?

    Thanks a bunch everyone.

  9. Jodi says:

    Hi Kris,

    Does the curcumin have a strong taste? I am not fond of turmeric, but would like to enjoy its benefits.

    Thanks!
    ~ Jodi

    • Morven Black says:

      Hi Jodi,
      I don’t like the taste either but I have found that if I mix it in with juice I don’t notice it at all. I use about 1/2 tsp in a juice. Mix it really well though, you don’t want to come across a lump of it..! 🙂

  10. Anne says:

    What vitamins are good for pd (tremors)
    Thanks

  11. Denise says:

    I have been looking forward to a comprehensive vitamin/mineral supplement guide!! Thank you Kris and Aviva!! I’m vegan so I supplement with vegan vitamins and minerals but definitely think I need a probiotic. Are all probiotics vegan, or do some come from milk cultures?

  12. Maia Marie says:

    Hello (: I have a pretty bad case of ms and wondering as to what supplements might incourage myelin repair if any?

    sincerely,
    maia

  13. Hi, I need help with pre-menopause, mood swings especially. I get so emotional, depressed, and angry. Please help! I am 49 years old. I would love a good recommendation.
    Thank you
    Laura

  14. Pat says:

    Just reading about supplements for women over 50 on your site and have a question regarding curcumin. I had read that the only way to really receive the ultimate benefits of curcumin was through the cooking process.. I am sixty one and have started adding fresh turmeric to as many dishes as possible.
    Now I am confused… I have not been adding turmeric to raw foods or juices and have stopped turmeric supplements completely. Please advise…

    • Kris Carr says:

      Hi Pat, Here’s Aviva’s advice:

      “Fresh turmeric is a wonderful anti-inflammatory herb that is also great for digestion. It can be used as a dried herb seasoning, or fresh in the many ways you already are. However, for max benefit, I use the curcumin, which is the “active ingredient” in turmeric, especially when my patients are struggling with autoimmune or inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis. – Aviva”

  15. Gail says:

    Thank you for the excellent article. I have found that my body does really well with Kyolic garlic. There are many different formulas and I have used various ones. When everyone is getting colds and flu, I take my odorless garlic capsules and get good protection. Recently I had a molar that started aching on the weekend and I realized that the tooth probably had died quite some time ago but I had been taking garlic and therefore didn’t get an infection or any aching until I ran out. I ran out to my local health food store and got a bottle of Kyolic Garlic and it tamed the tooth down until I could get it extracted a few days later. I had an incident while out of the country (food poisoning) and will never be without the garlic traveling again. Much to my surprise, upon returning home, I took some heavy doses of garlic, and found that my planter’s warts went away as a bonus since it’s anti-viral as well as anti-bacterial. Just this fall I added a multi-vitamin, Nature’s Way, Alive (Women’s 50+) and I’ve been very happy with the boost of energy I get. It’s all natural, made with 26 fruits and vegtables.

  16. Valerie says:

    So glad to read this information. I have gone through menopause early (40) I’m now 46 with the typical issues one gets with menopause. I do have one question about magnesium, should one take citrate and glycinate together?

    Thanks!

    • Kris Carr says:

      Hi Valerie, Here’s what Aviva had to say in response to your question:

      “Hi Valerie! Great Q! Both forms work great for bone health, restless legs, and sleep — the many wonders of magnesium. But citrate has the added benefit of helping with constipation. So if that’s an issue for you, then citrate is the best form; if not, glycinate. I’d combine them when you’ve reached your max on the citrate (meaning, your stools get a little loose for comfort) but you still need more for managing the other symptoms. Then I’d go up to the amount you need of citrate to keep your BMs comfy and daily, and top off the rest with the glycinate. Make sense? – Aviva”

  17. Cheryl says:

    Eating organically grown produce is a step in the right direction, but does not currently ensure that diet alone is providing the full spectrum of nutrients the body needs to maintain optimal health over the course of a lifetime. The food chain can no longer be relied on to provide the nutrients required for a healthy, vital life, providing the body with these nutrients directly is the only other option. Most people need supplements, children, men, women, prenatal, menopausal and over 50. The problem is that most vitamins don’t work because they are not being absorbed into the bloodstream, therefore giving vitamins a bad name. Minerals are like little rocks which makes them impossible for the body to absorb and utilize. When I became aware of this I researched a lot of different supplements and became a happy customer of a company called melaleuca. I am 45 years old and I have never felt better and I have tried lots of vitamins throughout my life. The real test for me was when I ran out of my melaleuca supplements and I felt tired and my bones were aching and then I realized it was because I stopped taking them. That never happened to me when I ran out of my one-a day or centrum. I also try and eat healthy but it’s not enough, I take a multivitamin, calcium, antioxidant, probiotic and cold water omega 3 that is made with wild-caught fish in deep cold waters and is molecularly distilled by water microdistillation without chemicals. These supplements have the only mineral-delivery technology formulated just like nature, proven by science to provide superior mineral absorbtion and maximum antioxidant protection and its patented. I will never need to take another supplement in my life, this company is years ahead of the rest. I also have my parents on them and they have never felt better and they even stopped taking some of their statin medications among other things. Melaleuca/Oligo.com and Freiburgstudy.com I don’t usually respond to these type of groups but knowing how much this has helped me & my family I just cant keep this to myself anymore!

  18. Kris Carr says:

    Hi Suzanne, Aviva reviewed your question & sent along this feedback:

    “I had a look at their website — looks like a company that’s been around for a long time and is trying to uphold high standards. It was hard to tell without looking at each product what their original source material quality is — but I agree, it does seem to be that they are going for quality! If you’ve been taking them and feel good about them — that seems like a good way to go. You could see if Consumer Labs has anything to say about them — but I believe that might require paying a membership fee. – Aviva”

  19. Sylvia says:

    Due to a recent thyroid surgey, and lots of blood being drawn and various doctors being seen, I have been doing OODLES of vitamin/supplement research. I am SO VERY pleased to read all of your recommendations– they are in alignment with what the most intelligent and helpful doctors suggested. Two thumbs up!
    Maybe I missed it, but I would also suggest peeps check their iron levels, because low iron is a mega energy zapper!

    XO
    Sylvia

  20. Rachel Sarah says:

    Big thanx to u both, Aviva and Kris! This was one of better and more comprehensive articles I read on supplementations for women in general- it’s always difficult to take a subject like this on bc we all have our own individual health needs but Aviva did an excellent job! I always look forward to reading ur newsletters, Kris! Please know that so many of us are uplifted and inspired on a daily basic by all of the love u put into providing these resources for us-

    I was a bit surprised to read some of the more negative and complaining comments. As a writer and photographer myself, I don’t know if some people realize the amount of work it takes to write articles like this and how difficult it can be to customize a health plan for every person out there.

    We all have to do our own research when it comes to checking out the quality of supplement makers and, of course, kris stands for eating whole foods and first getting nutrients from actual food-

    This article merely fills in the gaps between what we are eating and unable to get enough of- I found this a very spot-on list-

    Please think twice about the way that some of u offer feedback- there’s quite a difference between the way questions/critical feedback and negative criticism impacts the creator of something that has been “gifted” to all of us-

    For my part, kris and Aviva- Thank you so much for ur hard work and well written article! Focus on all of us who appreciate what u are doing in the world-

    Ps-

    Who would have thought a blog on supplementation would end up being so controversial and trigger so many people? 🙂

    Cheers-
    Rachel Sarah

    • Kris Carr says:

      Rachel, you rock. xo 🙂

    • Ruth says:

      Rachel Sarah, I really like your comments, thanks. I wonder what advice anyone would give regarding DHEA? There is so much FOR as AGAINST published here in Germany (always very critical on supplements). I am trying a low dose presently and for me it seems to work amazing well for general energy and MOOD! I started to sleep really well and a tendency towards slight depression has vanished. I should add that I am over 60, a freelancer working long days and long weeks (but doing what I love!!)
      Kind regards from Germany Ruth

1 2 3 4 5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KrisCarr.com