Wellness

What’s in My Makeup Bag?

read all about it

Hiya Gorgeous!

I’m a big believer that beauty comes from the inside out. It’s part of who we are, how we care for ourselves, speak to ourselves and feed ourselves.

Regardless of what the cosmetics companies promise, looking our best has more to do with consistent self-care and self-love vs quick fix potions. But that doesn’t mean that it can’t be fun or that there aren’t products out there that can enhance what’s already radiant (yes, you are already exquisite, the gloss just amplifies your natural shine, darling!).

While I’m a more natural kinda gal, I know how glamorous I feel when I get my makeup done for a photo shoot or big event. I’ve found some gems along the way, and today, I want to open my makeup bag so you can see what I’m currently using when it’s time to glam.

Since I don’t wear makeup every day (or even every week!), I don’t mind spending a little extra on high-quality products that I simply love.

What I put on my body is just as important as what I put in my body.

This means that I try to use products I know aren’t harmful—to me or any other creature.

Each of the products below has been vetted for their safety, toxicity, and animal cruelty. I always rely on one of my favorite organizations, the Environmental Working Group (EWG)—a leader in up-to-the-minute research on toxins and chemicals present in our personal and home products. EWG’s Skin Deep Cosmetic Database allows you to search products to ensure their safety. I also love Leaping Bunny and the Think Dirty app as alternative resources to find the safest products.

And while I try to keep everything as high-quality and organic as possible, I’ll be honest—I’m still searching for healthy options to products I just can’t quite find an alternative for! So I’d love to hear your suggestions, tips, favorite brands, and go-to products below in the comments.

And now, without further ado, if you dig around in my makeup bag, here’s what you’ll find!

Eyeshadow

I’m pretty fussy about eyeshadow. Texture is super important. There’s nothing worse than chalky shizzle that gets caught in my wisdom cracks (shall we say). Beautycounter and RMS beauty are solid brands I can always trust. But I also am a big fan of Urban Decay… a girl’s gotta shimmer from time to time.

Beautycounter eyeshadow (color: Shell/Malt) ($34)
RMS Sunset beach eyeshadow (color: #46) ($20)
Urban Decay eyeshadow (color: Sidecar) ($19)

Eyeliner

Nothing perks up my peepers than a nice black liner. I usually prefer pencil because it’s easy to glide on and I don’t have to worry about getting a little too dark. So I’ve shared two options, and I’ve also included a gel (which is applied with a brush) for those with a steady pair of hands.

W3ll People Hypnotist Eye pencil ($18.50)
Juice Beauty Phyto-Pigments Precision Eye Pencil ($20)
Pacifica Smolder Eye Lining Gel ($13.98)

Blush

A little dab of this on my cheeks and I feel like I got smooched (or pinched slightly hard) by cherubs. You can even use it on your lips. What I love about this blush is you can’t really overdo it.

Glossier Cloud Paint (color: Dusk and Beam) ($18)

Bronzer

A little bit goes a long way—that’s my mantra when it comes to bronzer. You don’t want to look like a Florida orange. This powder is so light, it adds just the perfect hint of color to make ya look sun-kissed.

Hourglass Ambient Lighting Powder (color: Luminous Light) ($46)

Concealer

This is my go-to concealer. I probably use this product the most out of everything listed here. It’s made to enhance skin, not just cover it up—hence the clever name!

RMS uncover ($36)

Mascara

Both of these options are wonderful. Mascara can be tricky because I always want it to look natural (not clumpy).

RMS Volumizing Mascara ($28)
W3ll People Mascara ($21.99)

Powder

Honestly, I’m not a big powder gal—until I tried this stuff. It’s super fine and I use it on its own or with foundation. And it’s available at Target!

W3ll People Powder ($24)

Blotting Papers

While I don’t use blotting papers every day, I do use these all the time on shoots. Rather than slathering on more powder, just blot off the shine. There are many brands out there, here’s one I’ve used from time to time.

Live Fresh Naturals ($6.99)

Primer and Foundations

I’m a big fan of both the Honest Beauty primer and foundation. I’ll put a little primer on first, then follow it up with the foundation. The two go hand-in-hand with each other. I thought I would never stray from this combo, until I came across the Gressa foundation. On a recent photo shoot, the makeup artist used it on me—and it was so light and fabulous! It’s formulated with rosehip seed oil and is all botanical too.

Honest Beauty primer (apply first) ($27)
Honest Beauty foundation ($30)
Gressa Skin Minimalist Corrective Serum Foundation (color: Light Medium/ #1.5 and #2) ($15)

Brow Filler

I’m obsessed with brows. True story: Back in college my girl friends used to call me Tweezer Bitch. Apparently, I was pretty good at taming and framing eyebrows. So good that gals lined up for free appointments with me and my tweezers. Today I love a good brow filler because it is a wonderful face framer. And they also can help to keep brows in their place. A two-fer!

Glossier Boy Brow  (color: Blond) ($16)
Beautycounter Color Define Brow Pencil ($23)
Jane Iredale PureBrow Brow Gel ($21)

Lipstick / Gloss

Throwing on a little color on my lips is one of my favorite beauty tricks. I love these products—some are more glossy and others are in lipstick form. Depending on how I’m feeling, I’ll switch up which one of these I use.

Honest Beauty (color: Generous Kiss) ($18)
Tata Harper (color: Be Adored) ($29)
Jane Iredale PureMoist Lipstick (color: Chloe) ($25)
Vapour Organic Beauty (color: Siren Au Pair) ($25)
Ilia (color: Hold Me Now) ($26)
Beautycounter Sheer Lipstick (color: Petal) ($30)

Your turn: What are your favorite beauty products? Let me know in the comments below—I’m looking to you to share your suggestions, as my beauty lineup is an ever-evolving work in progress!

Peace & Beauty,

Add a comment
  1. Kathy says:

    I like Boom by Cindy Joseph

  2. Anna Chilingarian says:

    I love you Kris Carr – Thank you!

  3. Jen says:

    This is wonderful, thank you for revealing your beauty favorites! I’m in need of some new mascara especially, and would like to start “reviving” my makeup collection with some more earth-friendly and body-loving alternatives. 🙂

  4. Wendy says:

    The RMS concealer looks awesome! Any suggestions how to choose the right shade?

  5. Laura says:

    I’ve been using cocoa powder for bronzer lately and I just love it! All natural and I smell like chocolate 🙂

  6. Shae says:

    What make-up brushes do you use?

  7. Katrina says:

    I recently made the switch from toxic beauty products to cleaner products. It has been a process for me. There aren’t enough local beauty stores that specialize in only non-toxic makeup. You really have to do your research, I’ve been told by many makeup artists that products are non-toxic blah blah and they have the worst ratings on Think Dirty App. I’ve found that a lot of natural foundations tend to be very orange. So far, my favorite beauty products have been…

    100% Pure coffee bean caffeine eye cream
    Nu Evolution Complete Coverage Foundation
    W3LL People bio Correct concealer
    Nu Evolution pressed Blush in Flushed (looks just like Nars Orgasm)
    W3LL People Mascara
    RMS beauty- has really pretty eye shadows. currently wearing Tempting Touch

    I haven’t found an eyeliner that I’m crazy about so I definitely will be trying the gel liner Kris listed above.

  8. Emily says:

    Everyday minerals (base powder, concealer, blush, face powder, &finishing powder) I believe they are $9-$18.
    Red Apple Lipstick (lipstick, eyeliner, mascara, eyeshadow, lip pencil, Lip gloss) $20-37 I think.

    Three thing I really love about Red Apple Lipstick is they are gluten free and they really care about where they source their ingredients from. Also their mascara FINALLY made my eyelashes stop falling out every time I wash my face!

  9. Regine says:

    I love the Pattyka products, especially the essential oil. Amazing!

  10. helen meleisea says:

    Hi Kris. I like using ‘NuSkin’ products. They are totally natural, no fillers etc. I too like natural products.

  11. Meaghan says:

    Aww, I was hoping to see Arbonne on your list; it totally aligns with your values and is friendly to the earth and animals.
    Sidebar: ewg is not always reliable… especially since some of its founders have their own skincare lines.

  12. Kris thank you for all of the awesome recommendations. My favorite for clean makeup and skincare products is Arbonne. They are Vegan and cruelty free. I am sure you get bombarded with things to try it, but if you get a wild hair and would like to try some samples let me know!

  13. Paryse Labrie says:

    A beautiful company founded by a passionate health and natural and vegan enthusiast offers completely natural essential oil based skin care and makeup here in Québec, Canada. They are high quality and really affordable products. The link to her website is: https://maisonjacynthe.ca/en/boutique

  14. Sue says:

    Hello Kris! Just wondering if the makeup reviewed above is available in Canada….or is it only available in the U.S.?
    Thanks.

  15. Laurie says:

    Thank you! I’ve been looking forward to this.

  16. Kaye says:

    Hi Kris!

    Thanks for the awesome list. I love the brow suggestions! Sadly for me 🙁 , the Beautycounter website states that the brow pencil contains fish oil. Thought I may point that out for others who avoid animal products in addition to the beeswax in the other two brow items that you already pointed out. I’m wondering if there are any brow products out there that are vegan and worth trying, ’cause my brows could really use some filling :-).

  17. Hi Kris!
    Young Living Essential Oils just introduced their cosmetic line. Amazing. I’m a distributor, for this brilliant and conscious company.
    Before their line, I’ve used Tarte. Great colors and textures, and no crease eye shadows.
    Thanks for your blog. Hit me up if you’re interested in YL products. Their essential oils are truly 100 percent therapeutic grade- they are the only company with a line of oils just for consumption.
    Enjoy your day.
    Cheryl

  18. Ruth Biersdorf says:

    I have been getting all of my cosmetics from Real Purity, realpurity.com, for several years. Check them out.

  19. Christina Patrick says:

    Why no “Milk” products? I’m “brow crazed” at the moment and their brow pencils are my favorite.
    The products are vegan and cruelty free, but a I don’t see a the leaping bunny. Let me know if they have some nefarious secrets.
    BTW – They also have adorable gender fluid tutorials, gorgeous kids.

  20. Elizabeth says:

    Love your approach…I go natural and green as much as possible without giving up performance. I like a lot of the makeup from 100% Pure. Also I swear by the Burt’s Bees Shimmer Sticks for color and protection. Rhubarb is my fave. And yes to Urban Decay…even if they’re not green and natural I am obsessed with the colors, wear and naughty names! Like Kris, I believe beauty come from within but I’m always checking out green makeup and Skincare on my happy, healthy and hot blog.

1 2 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KrisCarr.com