Blog Post

The Sugar Debate: To Quit or Not to Quit

read all about it

Hey Sweetness,

Are you afraid of bananas? I don’t mean literally, of course—but do you avoid higher-sugar fruits because you think they’re “bad” for you? This is something I want to discuss today.

Sugar is tricky. And in general, we should keep our sugar intake low.

Like most things that affect our health, though, it’s more complicated than that. Some health advocates aren’t acknowledging this, and are pushing a more black-and-white approach. I think telling the whole, detailed story is more helpful.

In this blog, I’ll cover my personal sugar story, the nuances of various types of sugar and how to reduce sugar in recipes. I’ll also outline what I believe is a healthy—physically, mentally and emotionally—approach to sugar. At the end of the day, it doesn’t have to be all or nothing and it really comes down to what works for you.

My sugar story

Way back in the day, I used to joke that I had a threesome every night with two guys named Ben and Jerry. In other words, ice cream (and all forms of sugar for that matter) were seriously seductive and addictive to me. I struggled through this rollercoaster relationship for years. Let me paint the painful picture for you: Most nights, I’d open up a fresh pint of ice cream and promise myself I’d have just a bite or two (hello, amnesia!). But then I’d quickly realize that I couldn’t put the spoon down. How did I stop? I’d use my dessert as my ash tray… Except that wasn’t enough—I’d just dig out the cigarette butt and ashes and keep going. Next (desperate) step? I’d spray it all down with cleaning supplies. That would finally stop me. Talk about dysfunction.

I tell you this to illustrate that I fully understand the power sugar can have over us. And as a nation, our sugar consumption has gotten completely out of control. Thankfully I have a new, healthier relationship with sugar now (and I kicked cigarettes to the curb a long time ago, too). I’ll nibble on some fruit or vegan dark chocolate when I want something sweet these days. Sugar isn’t the boss. I am. By changing my diet, resetting my tastebuds and dealing with the emotional stuff (important!), I was able to put sugar in its place. I’d say what helped me ditch the sweet stuff the most, though, was educating myself on all things sugar.

Not all sugar is created equal

One response to the sugar epidemic is to deem all sugars off-limits, but there’s a big difference between natural sugars and added sugars. The reason that government agencies and health experts make a point of discouraging “added sugars” is because these types of sugars are heavily processed and devoid of any natural nutrients. They bring our blood sugar up without supplying our bodies with anything healthful: a lose-lose situation.

Naturally occurring sugars—I’m talking about the sugars in fresh fruits and vegetables—deliver sweetness while also providing vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and concentrated stores of powerhouse phytonutrients.

The sugars in fruit (or sweeter vegetables, like carrots, beets and sweet potatoes) also come packaged with fiber, which helps us feel full and slows the absorption of sugar into our bloodstream. Plus, the micronutrients in fresh fruit may prevent the uptake of sugar in our small intestine. This means that many of us can enjoy the delightful sweetness and health benefits of fresh fruit without experiencing the drawbacks of mood-busting highs and lows and blood sugar spikes.

Not surprisingly, evidence shows that populations who eat more fruit have a lower BMI and lower risk of developing many chronic diseases, including high blood pressure, heart disease, stroke, certain cancers, type II diabetes, digestive diseases and obesity.

A sane approach to sugar

A healthy relationship with sugar is different for everyone. If you have special reason to be vigilant about the amount of sugar in your diet—for example, if you’re a cancer patient, or have diabetes or candida—then you may want to exercise some mindfulness even with naturally occurring sugars. For you, it may be wise to seek out fruits that are lower in sugar, and to use only moderate amounts of fruit and sweet veggies in your green drinks and meals. Avoiding refined and processed sugary treats as much as possible is a no-brainer when facing these challenges.

For those who need to swear off the sweet stuff, don’t despair. It’s possible to create tons of flavor and character in recipes without relying exclusively on sweet ingredients. One of my favorite tricks for brightening the taste of my juices and smoothies is to use fresh herbs, lemon, lime and ginger. Just because your juice or smoothie isn’t sweet, doesn’t mean it should be blah.

But for many people, I advocate finding some middle ground in the sugar struggle. A dogmatic approach of total avoidance—including naturally occurring sugars in produce—can lead to rebellion and bingeing (see: Ben & Jerry’s story). Not to mention all the missed out benefits that come from something as remarkable as a blueberry. Keeping sugar in check should not be about vilifying it or fearing it. It should be about making peace with it, living comfortably with it and understanding how much sugar feels good to each of us as individuals. The aforementioned banana could be a no-no for some, but could be hugely healthful for others. It’s up to each of us to determine how much sugar is right for our bodies and lifestyles.

 

 

A low-sugar sweet treat

In addition to fruit and dark chocolate, I love to satisfy my sugar cravings with naturally sweet (and mega-nutritious) smoothie and nut milk recipes. Here’s a super-delicious and superbly healthy nut milk to sip on when you’re jonesin’ for something sweet. It’s from my new book, Crazy Sexy Juice, and I just know you’re going to love it. And by the way, a big thank you to everyone who left a review on Amazon! Your praise means the world to me. It’s why I do what I do. Now on to the recipe…

Chocolate Almond Milk

vegan chocolate milk recipe
Yields 3.5-4 cups

  • 1 cup almonds, soaked for 8 hours
  • 2 to 3 pitted Medjool dates
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 4 cups water
  • 2 tablespoons cacao powder
  • 1/4 teaspoon cinnamon (optional)

1. In a high-speed blender, blend the almonds, dates, salt, and water till totally smooth.

2. Create a large, double layer of cheesecloth and hold it over a large mixing bowl, or hold a nut milk bag over a large mixing bowl. Pour the almond milk through the cheesecloth or bag and squeeze thoroughly. You can compost or discard the nut pulp.

3. Transfer strained almond milk back to your blender. Add the cacao and cinnamon, if using. Blend till smooth.

4. Transfer the nut milk to an airtight container. It will keep in the fridge for about 3 days.

Now I’d love to hear from you: What’s your approach to sugar? OR what’s your biggest sugar hang-up?

Peace & nanas,

Add a comment
  1. Jo & Jules says:

    Excellent explanation! Everyone’s body is made differently, and so is every sugar product. We should certainly take caution when eating sugary foods, though.

  2. Matheo says:

    I have personally found that my sugar cravings are reduced when I am focused on my important priorities and doing work that I love, connected what gives me meaning.
    When we are inspired by what we do we experience less need for addictions and excesses.
    When I am distracted by meaningless work and then have to catch-up on my meaningful work my level of stress increases and along with it my desire for sugar.

  3. kristie Serio says:

    I would recommend Lisa Musician. She is a AllerCoach and a Registered Dietician.

  4. Stephanie says:

    Hello i stopped tahing sugar montgs ago but recently i started putting natural turbinado sugar in my oats, grits and etc.. Is it healthy and is that ok.. Since its not refined sugar.

  5. Maiysa says:

    Thanks Kris for the great article! You are my inspiration!! I believe I posted my question in the wrong reply box. My question is how much sugar do you allow on average, fructose and all, not added sugar but natural sugars in a day? I read that 24 grams a day is typical for woman or 6 teaspoons of sugar. I wrote my story on someone else’s post, but to recap, I am an ex cancer patient, I have mast cell disease and liver disease with lots of fatty liver, even though I am 5′ 6″ and weigh 118 pounds, give or take. But me loves me sugar, mostly fruit but feel this might be part of my liver issue. I have read lots of negative things about sugar, especially fructose and its effects on the liver. I am also for some strange reason, now pre diabetic. I am an extremely healthy eater, but think I have been adding too much sugar to my veggie juice. I add an apple or two, with carrots as my sweetners just about daily. I also eat a date or two and my total sugar, fructose and all, for one day was almost 100 grams of sugar. Yikes!!! That’s not every day, but a few days. All good sugar, but I am obviously not processing it properly and it’s way too much!. If anyone else can answer my question, that would be helpful. But would really like to know how much you allow Kris. (I will check my Crazy Sexy Diet book to see if you list the answer there) It’s my second week off sugar. But noticed if I don’t eat enough, I start to not feel well also. Thanks!

    • Zuzana says:

      Hi Malysa, I am not an expert but I do believe that natural sugar in fruits cannot do you any harm. It seems to me that you are a bit overstressed over the matter (I am not critisizing you, this is just a friendly advice). Maybe you could try to get relaxed and trust your body a bit more. In Crazy Sexy Diet you find many tips on the inner work. Healthy diet is very important but your inner attittude is equally important. Fear and stress over the “right amount” of sugar is not good for you. I send you lots of love.

      • Maiysa says:

        Zuzana, Thank you for taking the time to reply. I don’t know how I came off overstressed, but thank you for caring. Maybe it was from me posting too much and trying to figure out the right place to post?. I was very active on the old blog-CSD and am usually just an observer on this one. The “I should trust my body more” comment made me laugh. As well intended as it was, it was bad timing. 🙂 I just got home after hours at a hospital hooked up to an infusion. Anaphylaxis, tachycardia, rash and feeling like something awful had invaded my body hit at 4 am while in a gentle sleep. I have mast cell activation and dysautonomia. I was a healthy person, and literally over night my amazing healthy life changed, and now I don’t know from moment to moment what food, pollen, virus, or a tiny chemical smell is going to do to my body. Desperate? Maybe. I heard today from a man that I had a 5 minute encounter with- Hope is the last to die. After 9 years, I still have hope and I look for anything that can help me just to get even 1% better from my daily struggle. And at 4 am, Meditation and deep breathing of trying to beat the anxiety that goes with feeling like you are dying, was the only thing that kept me from having to call an ambulance. But I do appreciate the reminder, and truly wish I could trust my body more. I watched Kris transform her health and I hold onto every morsel of information she has, so if I seem desperate to know how much sugar, it’s not out of stress, but out of survival.

  6. michelle says:

    I am confused as i understand you have cancer. How do you add so much dates or sometimes bananas to your smoothies or drinks?

  7. Nicole says:

    Do you think the added refined sugar in the ben&jerrys was really the worst/most addicting part about the ice cream, though? From what I have learned over my health journey, a little refined sugar here and there is no big deal. When people start sugar shaming they usually relate sugar to foods like ice cream, doughnuts, cake, and cookies. Personally, I do not think the sugar in these treats is the bad part, but rather the processed oils and animal fats. Don’t be afraid of fruit and it’s okay to sprinkle some brown sugar on your morning oats, its when you pair refined sugars or any sugars with sticks of butter and refined oils that your body has trouble handling the sugar. Sugar on its own really is not that scary. Of course, keeping intake to whole food sources (like fruit) will always be healthiest.

  8. I love this blog post! I try to control my sugar intake when it comes from refined sugars, wich I don’t touch if I can avoid them. I do it because I want to, not because I need to.
    But sometimes I feel bad because I didn’t do it as strict as I’m supposed to be because I eat fruit… But you’re right, it depends on you, and balance is always better than a strict restriction. Fruit is still on my diet, I just have caution with the amount and the frequency.
    You’re an inspiration, Kris… !!
    Hugs from Spain!

  9. Caroline says:

    Sugar is sweet and so is laughter, play and intimacy. Enjoy ALL the sweetnesses daily so the bittersome days don’t seem so soul crushing 🙂

  10. Kate Allen says:

    Thanks so much Kris 🙂 Finally an article about sugar that is balanced. Our Cells need natural natural sugar!! I own an organic cafe and market in Adelaide South Australia and I am saddened by how many people see fruit and veggies that contain natural sugar as the enemy. Obviously refined sugar is a completely different story – but the nutrients in foods that contain natural sugars is so important for great wellbeing x

  11. Heather says:

    Did you give up fruit sugar with your cancer? Or do you limit fruit? I’m a cancer survivor and people tell me I shouldn’t eat fruit even though I’m trying to go high raw and fruit is where the calories are. I have always been confused no matter how much I research it. It just seems to me like natural fruit and veggies are the way to go, I think 50/50 of each is good but some people make me feel bad about too many bananas in my smoothies. Even though I eat a ton of greens as well…..So confusing. 🙂 xo

    • Nicole says:

      whole fruits and veggies are the healthiest most healing foods on the planet and should always be consumed in abundance with no restrictions. if you are eating a lot of fruit with high sugar content and you are having a negative experience, try lowering your fat intake and that will help your body more easily digest and absorb the sugars.

  12. Bec says:

    Thanks for this Kris 🙂 Most people don’t realise how addictive sugar is. I eat a couple of serves of fruit a day but other than that, almost no sugar in anything I eat/ cook. Once I gave up lollies, chocolate etc, I wasn’t even tempted at all.
    In my work place is a lolly jar metres from my desk, plus scones, cake etc often on offer and I don’t even consider having any. I just don’t crave it at all, since I gave it up. Which goes to show how awfully addictive it is.
    Looking forward to investing in one of your books soon! 🙂 Love all your blog posts.

  13. Robin says:

    I recently met with an iridologist/nutritionist and she prescribed a yeast elimination diet for me. I have had a sweet tooth forever and would welcome any recipes for anything chocolate that is sugar, gluten, soy, gluten free, and without fruit with the exception of fresh berries. Also must be vegan! HELP?!

  14. Cassandra says:

    Thanks so much for all that you do and for all that you are. You have been a blessing to me and to my type 1 diabetic daughter who is now using your diabetic friendly recipes and guidance from the new book to juice. She is 21 this month and a nursing student in college. Her blood sugar has been hard to control recently but since she started juicing and eating a primarily vegan diet it’s become great. Her endocrinologist is on board with it and is excited about her desire and drive for self care. He said he wished more of his patients had her drive and dedication to be the CEO of their health destiny.
    I was diagnosed with Celiac and Candida the week before Thanksgiving. It feels good to finally have answers as I have been sick and searching for nearly 3 decades with clueless Dr’s. I now see a functional NP and she is the one who finally figured it out. I decided that trying to do gluten and sugar free the week before the holidays was a bad idea. I felt as if I’d set myself up for failure so I started on Sunday. I’m using stevia and xylitol as my sweeteners and have removed high sugar fruit/veg from my juices/smoothies for now. Your new book has been incredibly helpful. I juice daily for breakfast and lunch and eat a whole foods vegan diet. I’ll add a few of the lower sugar fruits/veg back in once the candida cleansing and healing is over but never plan to go back full force.
    By the way, I also have your meditation album and that has been a Godsend as well. I use it daily and have found it helpful during this sugar cleanse.
    We are sooo very grateful for all that you do and we keep you in our prayers and thoughts always.
    ((((((Love and hugs)))))))

  15. Tammy Morris says:

    Love your Crazy Sexy Juice! My eating habits are not 100%, but improving all the time. Thank you for sharing your knowledge.

  16. Rachel says:

    I get addicted to sugar when I start eating refined sugar or artificial sweeteners tucked in some food, which is why I usually avoid them. I’m fine on the naturally occurring sugar in fruit though. When I’m going through sugar withdrawals (like, after Christmas for example) I will have tea with honey, or oatmeal with maple syrup, just to help beat the cravings. Usually I don’t need anything though (besides fruit!) and I like it that way. I find I can taste so many more flavors without it plus I have more energy!

  17. Liza says:

    The most effective thing I have done to reduce sugar cravings is follow a 80-90% plant-based diet. Once I stopped eating meat, dairy, and eggs on a regular basis, my intense sugar and fat cravings virtually disappeared!

    My theory: eating a plant based diet provides more natural sugars than I would allow myself to eat on the SAD diet. I used to restrict my carbohydrate and calorie intake to lose weight, but as a reaction to starvation mode, I would ultimately binge on processed sugar/fat.

    Now, I fuel up on frozen banana “nice” cream, dates, goji berries, dark chocolate, apples, blueberries…. you name it! Fruit is no longer a restricted food for me and as a result, I get all the warm and fuzzies my brain needs.

    I’ve lost 10 pounds since I started this approach in August and have managed to change my relationship with food and my body. I owe it to Kris and the supportive online vegan community!

    xo Liza

    • Maiysa says:

      Hello Kris! I am a schmanser patient (thyroid) but am clear of the C word. Yay! I am a healthy eater, but have mast cell disease (can’t eat most histamine foods due to anaphylaxis) and now own a diseased liver that includes too many cysts to count and fatty liver. But me likes me suga! Not in candy or processed, but I juice a few apples and carrots in my veggie juice and also eat a few dates a day. I added it up one day and it was almost 100 grams of sugar and read fructose is not good for the liver. I didn’t realize I was eating that much sugar a day. Am now on a low sugar band wagon, (also just found out I am pre diabetic) even though I am 5’6″ and weigh 118 pounds. Might be from the mast cell disease or the fruit I am thinking.) Anyhow, about how much sugar can one have a day? And do you try to keep yours under a certain amount? I find that if I don’t eat any, I get really sick as well, so I know i need some.
      Thanks!

  18. Gemma Rose says:

    Thank you Kris for setting the sweet record straight!
    Lots of love and blessings for 2016!
    Xo
    Gemma Rose

  19. Cantsay says:

    Sorry but that smoothie sounds disgusting. I’ll stick with my bananas.

    • Kris Carr says:

      There isn’t a smoothie recipe in this article, it’s a nut milk. And that’s all you got out of it? Disgusting? Let’s try to elevate the energy a bit around here, because the energy we bring to the online world truly matters. Best wishes, Kris

  20. Melanie says:

    Hi Kris… Great article..the whole concept of ‘it’s different for everyone’ is so true and also different at different times in your life. I used to be able to eat sugar of all types no problems, but now, even the slightest bit of processed refined sugar makes my brain turn slightly suicidal-quite scary really. When I’m sugar free I’m so much happier without even ‘trying’… I think if anyone is experiencing Depression I highly recommend try cutting sugar completely (even fruit at first then slowly introduce to see if you can handle it) and see they feel better…it’s a small price to pay for having a mind that has the ability to think clearly and positively. 🙂 xx

1 2 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KrisCarr.com