Kris Carr

Kris Carr

Blog Post

Are Juices or Smoothies Healthier?

read all about it

Hiya Gorgeous,

If I had a dollar for every time I’ve been asked, “What’s the difference between juicing and blending?” I could open an animal sanctuary and pay for you all to come and visit!

I began incorporating both juices and smoothies into my diet over 16 years ago when my cancer diagnosis had me searching for ways to give my body the support and nutrition it needed. Juicing and blending became—and have remained—staples in my feel-great plan ever since. They’re also important parts of the wellness plans I create, such as Crazy Sexy You (my 21-day total wellness program).

And while these practices have become increasingly popular in the last several years, some of you may still be confused about their differences and benefits. Each method has its unique perks, but rest assured they’re both fabulous ways to incorporate nutrition-packed produce into your diet.

 

The Benefits of Juicing

Juicing extracts the liquid from the fruits and vegetables, leaving the majority of the fiber behind. By removing the fiber, all of the nutrients in the plant’s juice—vitamins, minerals, enzymes—instantly flood our bodies with goodness, especially when enjoyed first thing in the morning before any other food hits your system. Just think of the added volume of veggies you can pack in your belly, sweet unicorn! Even those of us with the heartiest of appetites would find it challenging to consume the same amount of raw vegetables and fruits with a fork.

Juices also give your digestive system a little rest by removing most of the fiber (which takes a lot of energy to digest). Since your body works hard on your behalf 24/7, it’s nice to give it some R&R. That’s not to say you should avoid fiber—it’s super important for you and helps keep ya regular. But if you’re upgrading your overall diet to include lots of plant-based, whole foods, you’ll be getting plenty of it, especially if you include smoothies and healthy, home-cooked chow.

Got digestive ouchies? Juicing is a great option for folks whose digestive systems are too sensitive to handle lots of fiber, or for those getting used to a plant-rich diet. If that’s you, juicing ensures you can enjoy the benefits of boatloads of awesome produce without suffering any tummy troubles for your efforts. For people focused on healing or repair in general, juices offer maximum health benefits in a gentle, easy-to-digest, easy-to-assimilate form. I’ve also heard that some folks get turned off by the texture of smoothies. If that’s you, then juicing is a fantastic option!

Keep in mind that green juices aren’t complete meals, whereas smoothies can be. Some folks enjoy a green juice first thing in the morning or for an afternoon pick-me-up. If you have a juice in the morning and don’t want a full meal right away, make sure to grab a hearty mid-morning snack to keep your energy up. If you want your afternoon green juice to have more staying power, enjoy it with a handful of nuts or seeds. This will help you make sure you’re getting all of the essential nutrients you need, including the protein and fiber juices don’t include.

To ensure your green juices aren’t too high in fruity sugar, use three servings of veggies for every one serving of fruit. Or go veggie crazy and just use some lemon, lime, ginger, carrots or romaine to add tangy sweetness to your drinks. The lower the sugar, the more effective the green juice will be at boosting your immune system and fighting inflammation.

The Benefits of Green Smoothies

Blending on the other hand… blends! The ingredients are whirled and pureed into scrumptious smoothies that provide the benefits of fruits and veggies along with their heart-healthy, gut-friendly fiber. Folks who are watching their blood sugar sometimes prefer blending to juicing because the fiber ensures a slow and steady absorption of sugar into your bloodstream.

Besides all the great fiber, smoothies allow you to use fantastic foods that juicers can’t always handle. Take sprouts, for instance—those tiny powerhouses of plant nutrition. Sprouts will shoot right through a centrifugal juicer without getting juiced, but they blend up perfectly in smoothies. Nut butters and superfood powders can give you (and your energy levels) a powerful boost, but they can’t be juiced. Blend them up, though, and you’re on your way to all sorts of flavorful and even medicinal drinks.

Smoothies have another important advantage: They can help you feel fuller longer. Protein, fiber, healthy fats and complex carbs create sustainable energy. If you fill up your smoothies with lots of nutrient-packed ingredients, they can even serve as well-rounded, convenient and delectable meals. Plus, they support healthy digestion because of the fiber and other nutritious ingredients.

When blending up your delish smoothies, include at least one veggie for every two fruits. Start with a tightly packed cup of leafy greens like spinach or kale, and add a cup of frozen fruit (such as frozen berries or mango, or raw fruit plus a cup of ice) and a banana or avocado for creaminess. Then pour in your liquid of choice (unsweetened nondairy milk, water, coconut water, etc.), filling the blender up to the level of the other ingredients. If you’re feeling adventurous, sneak in a tablespoon or two of hemp seeds, almond butter or other nuts/seeds for protein, and top it off with bonus superfoods like matcha, cacao, maca, spirulina or chia seeds. Blend and go! This formula will serve one to two people depending on appetite.

Juicing vs. Blending: The Bottom Line

Both juicing and blending are wonderful and efficient ways to maximize your consumption of the good stuff: greens, vegetables, fruits and superfoods. My healthy, plant-powered diet features juices AND smoothies, and I wouldn’t have it any other way!

Let’s do a quick recap of the awesome bennies these two types of green drinks have to offer!

Green Juices:

  • Flood your cells with nutrition almost instantly—that’s why I call it liquid sunshine!
  • Contain minimal fiber, making it easy on sensitive tummies.
  • Give your digestive system a break by doing the chewing for you, making juicing a super efficient way for your body to take advantage of all of those fab plant-powered nutrients.
  • Pack lots of raw produce (far more than you could realistically eat if you were consuming it another way) into a single delicious drink!

Green Smoothies:

  • Can serve as complete meals filled with protein, calcium and lots of green goodness.
  • Allow you to mix in superfood powders, seeds and other nutritious foods that juices can’t.
  • Keep the fiber in, which helps you stay regular and other great stuff!
  • Blenders are usually easier to clean juicers, which can make this habit more sustainable for busy peeps like you!

My hope is that over time, you’ll find yourself enjoying smoothies and juices. They both offer incredible health benefits that will boost your overall well-being for life. Plus, variety is the key to achieving the kind of balance you need to thrive—and it keeps things exciting! Why choose between a refreshing Classic Green Lemonade and an indulgent Chocolate Avocado Smoothie when you can have both?!

Whatever you do, choose what keeps you happy and motivated to drink your way to wellness. Cheers!

Your turn: Do you drink more juices or smoothies? Does it vary with time of day, your energy, your appetite, the weather, the season… ? Tell me in the comments below—I love to hear about others’ super-drink habits!

Peace & healthy bevvies,

Add a comment
  1. Dennis Mann says:

    Juicing & Blending are two of the most useful tools in my self-care toolkit. I started juicing after a diagnosis of canSr onApril fool’s day of 2013. Since then, with the help of a Crazy Sexy cookbook I’ve added smoothies an eliminated many products harmful to getting healthier. Thanks so much C.S., would be wondering the woods without Your guidance. Peace and Joy.

  2. Lisa Love says:

    I was faithfully doing 10-day – 2-week juice cleanses with a salad mid day, every 3 months. But I got a little worried that it was to hard on my body when I suddenly experienced a migraine while cleansing during my menses. I want to incorporate a green juice now in the afternoons and maybe try a shorter cleanse. I miss the good feeling of it! Reading this article inspires me to get back on the path. Otherwise, I generally have a blueberry, kale, coconut almond milk smoothie with Raw Meal for breakfast 3-4 days/ week.
    Thank you for re-inspiring me, Chris. You are such a role model for joyful juicing.

  3. Janis Marchese says:

    I only have a blender and it seems to work for me. I may invest in a juicer now that I officially know the difference but I’m happy blending. Thanks for the info.

    Janis

  4. Susan Kutz says:

    I have a smoothie just about every morning. As a critical care RN, I sometimes don’t get to eat lunch until 2 or 3 PM. I have my smoothie at 5:15 AM. It’s a long stretch between breakfast and lunch and the smoothie keeps me going until I get a chance to eat lunch.

  5. Jejja Skarin says:

    I love love love the inspiration you give! Thank you darling Kris for being a wellness/animal-advocating warrior:-)//Jejja in Sweden

  6. Alison says:

    Question, my daughter is about to start chemo. She has been advised not to eat or consume anything raw. What is your suggestion for either juicing or smoothies for her?

    • Kris Carr says:

      You may want to wait till after the chemo if your doctor doesn’t advise it. Some patients have used vinegar or diluted food grade hydrogen peroxide to clean the fruits and veggies thoroughly as to avoid potentially harmful bacteria.

      Sending love to you and your daughter, Alison. xo, kc

  7. heidi says:

    I prefer juicing due to the fact that is feels cleaner. but the clean up requires more time. I do however love my vitamix tor fruit smoothies and dissolving powders and very easy clean up. I was diagnosed w Brest cancer 5 years ago. I read your books and have been using my breville and vitamix ever since. after a double mastectomy chemo reconstruction a total hysterectomy. you have been an inspiration to me and I thank you!!! I look forward to preordering. I cannot wait to receive your latest book. and thank you again✌️ and green drinks

  8. Joyce Olszewski says:

    Hi Kris,
    What juicer do you recommend? Looking for something that is efficient but easy to clean up, thanks!!

    • Kris Carr says:

      Hi Joyce,

      For efficiency and easy clean-up, I’d go with a centrifugal juicer. Some good ones to check out: Breville Ikon Multi-Speed, Breville Juice Fountain Compact (a smaller juicer, great for apartment living), and the Omega 4000.

      Hope that helps!

  9. Suzette Rose says:

    I recently read an interesting article that had researched actual nutritional values for juices vs. smoothies (I thought I had saved it but I cannot find it.) I have been a Vitamix girl for years, so the results were surprising. The nutritional values in juicing far outweigh (about 2-3 times) the values of blending. Juicing extracts all of the nutrients from the plants but it does not completely pulverize them, as happens with blending. Blending breaks the nutrients down to such an extent that not much nutrition is left. And to get 1/2 – 1/3 of the nutrients of an identical-ingredient juice, only blend for 12 seconds maximum!

  10. Natalia says:

    I am stage 4 breast cancer, im going sugarless, green, meatless for a year now but all I have is a nutribullet, is that enough? Is it consider a blender or a juicer? BTW I preorder your new book months ago and I cant wait for it to come… Xoxo

    • Kris Carr says:

      Hi Natalia,

      The NutriBullet you’re talking about is probably a blender. You can definitely make good smoothies with it, and here’s something to try if you want to give one of the juice recipes a go: Blend up all the ingredients, making sure to discard all the tough stems, seeds and skins and add in enough liquid (purified water, coconut water, etc.) to keep that blender moving. Then pour the mixture into a nut milk bag, squeeze over a bowl and you’ve got juice 🙂

      Sending you love & support!

  11. Jen says:

    I have been following you for some time since my 10 year old son was diagnosed with brain cancer in 2010. He is now in remission. I recently have been having lots of random problems…and they are thinking I have a mast cell disorder. I am hoping that juicing will help heal a bit, and I can continue to find out about this disorder.
    Thanks for being inspiring!!
    Jen

  12. Thanks so much for this great, informational article Kris! I literally was just wondering yesterday about the differences between blending and juicing. I have a Vitamix and make smoothies regularly. I’m working with a health coach. He recently loaned me his juicer talking about the power of making juice too. Your article helps me understand the benefits of each and to increase my confidence about listening to my body to know which one I want when! Thank you for everything you do! Stephanie

  13. Jillian says:

    Hi Kris!

    Loved reading this, I’m a smoothie girl, but just finished up 6 months of chemo and have been looking into juicing as a way to get more nutrients.

    I also have started meditating since my diagnosis, and love it, so I was super excited to hear people who pre order Crazy Sexy Juice will get your meditation recordings. I preordered on Amazon a while ago, will I still have access to the meditation recordings?

    Thanks!
    Jillian

  14. dear kris,

    i cant wait for your new book is coming out! i used to drink smoothies, but since 2 weeks im the owner of a gastroback juicer. i feel great, i love it! i wonder if the blender `bianco` is common in the us. i think its a better blender then vitamix. and it is not as loud as vitamix.

    greets from germany,
    pia

  15. Maiya says:

    I LOVE Juicing and have been making a delicious green juice just about every morning since I got my juicer in May. I bought my nearly new Breville juicer on Craig’s List! I am addicted to the natural ‘boost’ I get of clarity and energy in the morning from my green juice. Also, I’m not a big breakfast eater and enjoy the lighter feeling in my stomach while still getting a big nutritional benefit I can feel all day long! . Can’t wait for the book! Thanks for all the inspiration Kris!

  16. Betsy says:

    I usually break my 16 hr. fast with a smoothie to kinda get things primed for lunch. I tend to drink my juices with meals to help rack up the veggie count without getting overstuffed. Due to hyperinsulinism, I keep the fruit content on the low side mostly. Sometimes, though, the carrot orange is just too tempting to pass up!

  17. Darcy says:

    I can’t wait for the book!!!

  18. Deb says:

    I’m a “smoothie girl”. My Vitamix and I spend a lot of time together:)

  19. Kristin says:

    Thank you for summarizing the benefits of both! I definitely prefer smoothies (maybe because I like to minimize the number of kitchen gadgets I have and I already have an awesome blender!), but some of the flavor combinations you provide for juice recipes sound fantastic! Is there a simple way to convert a juice recipe to a smoothie recipe? Maybe just adding some water…?

  20. Diana says:

    Do you also have lots of juices/smoothies receipies for kids and teens in your new book?

    Thx!

1 2 3 4 5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KrisCarr.com